Loading...
Final 2024 0808 Special Meeting PacketMoses Lake City Council Dustin Swartz, Mayor | Judy Madewell, Deputy Mayor | Don Myers, Council Member | Mark Fancher, Council Member Deanna Martinez, Council Member | David Skaug, Council Member | Victor Lombardi, Council Member Thursday, August 8, 2024 Moses Lake Civic Center – 401 S. Balsam Joint Meeting with Planning Commission Special Meeting Agenda Call to Order – 5:30 p.m. Development Code Update Study Session (Continuation of 9 prior meetings in June and July) Attached edits to draft 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Next Review: Boundary Line Adjustment and Binding Site Plan Adjournment Next Regular Council Meeting is scheduled for August 13, 2024 NOTICE: Individuals planning to attend the in-person meeting who require an interpreter or special assistance to accommodate physical, hearing, or other impairments, need to contact the City Clerk at (509) 764-3703 or Deputy City Clerk at (509) 764-3713 at least 24 hours in advance of the meeting. Link to information on the development code update can be found from the homepage cityofml.com. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 COMMUNITY AND PROJECT DESIGN STANDARDS Chapter 15.705 COMMUNITY DESIGN STANDARDS Chapter 15.710 PROJECT DESIGN STANDARDS Chapter 15.715 PARKING Chapter 15.720 LANDSCAPING AND BUFFERING Chapter 15.725 FENCES, SCREENING, AND REFUSE STORAGE STANDARDS Chapter 15.730 NONCONFORMING USES AND STRUCTURES Chapter 15.735 SIGNS Chapter 15.740 OUTDOOR LIGHTING Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 2 of 57 Chapter 15.705 COMMUNITY DESIGN STANDARDS Sections: 15.705.010 Compliance with Standards and Guidelines. 15.705.020 Sidewalks, Multi-Use Pathways, and Street Trees. 15.705.030 Street Design. 15.705.040 Performance Standards. 15.705.050 Pedestrian Standards. 15.705.060 Shoreline Master Program. 15.705.070 Community Street and Utility Standards and City Design Standards. 15.705.080 Structures over Easements or Right-of-Way. 15.705.090 Maintenance of Lots. 15.705.100 Maintenance of City Right-of-Way. 15.705.110 Issuance of a Business License or a Certificate of Occupancy. 15.705.120 Vehicle Maintenance. 15.705.130 General Residential Performance Standard. 15.705.010 Compliance with Standards and Guidelines. A. Application. All development shall comply with the design standards and guidelines applicable to the type of use and/or the district in which the proposed development is located. The Director, or other decision maker so specified, shall have the authority to apply the standards to specific development proposals as conditions of approval. B. Standards Adopted by Reference. This Chapter recognizes and incorporates the standard details for construction of public improvements, as it exists now or as it may hereafter be amended. The City Council has established by resolution the standard details for construction of public improvements, and other matters pertaining to the MLUDC. The standard details for construction of public improvements shall be kept by the City Engineer or the City Clerk and may be altered or amended by resolution of the City Council. Where conflicts or inconsistencies arise between the standard details for construction as approved by resolution of the City Council and those in other code requirements, the standard details for construction as approved by resolution of the City Council supersede those in other code requirements. Referenced guidelines or standards: 1. Comprehensive Plan 2. Community Street and Utility Design Standards 3. Trails and Activity Paths 4. Parks, Recreation & Open Space Plan 5. Shoreline Master Program 6. Stormwater Management Manual for Eastern Washington 7. Complete Streets 8. Housing Action Plan 9. Wastewater Facility Plan 10. Water System Plan C. Minimums. The standards and requirements established or referenced by this Chapter are minimum requirements. These standards may be increased and additional Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 3 of 57 requirements may be imposed for the purpose of mitigating identified probable significant adverse environmental impacts pursuant to the State Environmental Policy Act, Chapter 43.21C RCW, as now established or hereafter amended. Such additional requirements may include, but shall not be limited to, off-site improvements to any public facility, the dedication or improvement of parks and open spaces, and monetary contributions to any City fund established to finance the provision of public services D. Conflict. These standards are intended to supplement other provisions of the MLUDC and other existing City codes applicable to developments. Where there is a conflict between the provisions of this Chapter and other codes, the most stringent shall apply. E. Chapter Not Exclusive. Compliance with the provisions of this Chapter does not constitute compliance with other federal, state, and local regulations and permit requirements that may be required (for example, Shoreline Substantial Development Permits, Hydraulic Permit Act (HPA) permits, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Section 404 permits, National Pollution Discharge Elimination System permits). The Applicant is responsible for complying with these requirements. 15.705.020 Sidewalks, Multi-Use Pathways, and Street Trees. A. Sidewalks Multi-Use Pathways, and Street Trees. The following standards are applicable: 1. Width: Unless otherwise specified in the referenced guidelines or standards the minimum sidewalk width shall be five feet plus accommodations for street trees, plantings, applicable stormwater, and curb. Multi-use pathways, designed per standards and guidelines Community Street and Utility Design Standards, shall be used in place of a standard sidewalk for all streets. 2. Street Trees and Plantings within Right-of-way (planter strip): Shall comply with the requirements of MLUDC Chapter 15.720. B. Multi-use Pathways. 1. Multi-use pathways, designed per standards and guidelines herein, may be used in place of a standard sidewalk for all streets. 2. Multi-use pathways shall be constructed to WSDOT’s Shared Use Path design standards (Chapter 1515 of the WSDOT Design Manual). This includes a minimum paved width of ten (10) feet. 15.705.030 Street Design. A. Streets, sidewalks, water, wastewater, stormwater and miscellaneous utility infrastructure shall be laid out in a manner which allows for accessibility, further development of all parcels within the region, and well-designed networks and circulation. B. The Applicant is responsible for constructing all the streets within the subdivision full width, and all the streets adjacent to the subdivision half width. Except, the Applicant shall be responsible for constructing the adjacent streets full width if the City determines that the use within the subdivision requires full width streets. C. The Applicant shall be required to design easements and dedications in a manner which facilitates the future development of the region as determined by the Director. This Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 4 of 57 shall be accomplished by establishing easements and dedications to the furthest lot line, as well as other similar methods. Cul-de-sacs are limited and only allowed authorized by the Director upon consultation with the City Engineer. D. All easements and dedications shall be designed in a manner which provides the necessary dimensional specifications required for future development. E. All lots shall be provided with direct access to an improved public street meeting the specifications contained in the MLUDC and as designated in the Comprehensive Plan. Streets shall be improved to the standards as outlined in the MLUDC and as a condition of development approval. All streets shall be dedicated to the City, except as provided in MLUDC Chapter 15.330. F. Development standards shall be reviewed concurrently with the related application for a building permit, utility connection permit, land use permit, subdivision permit, or other associated type of activity or permit. G. Those public facilities and utilities required to be provided as a condition of approval shall be fully operational or bonded for concurrency with the use and occupancy of the development, except that concurrency for transportation facilities may be within six (6) years of project approval at the discretion of the Director working in consultation with the Public Works Director. H. Development shall be prohibited if the development causes the level of service on a locally owned transportation facility to decline below the standards adopted in the transportation element of the comprehensive plan, unless transportation improvements or strategies to accommodate the impacts of development are made concurrent with the development. These strategies may include increased public transportation service, ride-sharing programs, demand management, and other transportation systems management strategies. For the purposes of this subsection, “concurrent with the development” means that improvements or strategies are in place at the time of development, or that a financial commitment is in place to complete the improvements or strategies within six years. Highways of statewide significance are exempt from concurrency requirements, pursuant to RCW 36.70A.070(6)(a)(iii)(C). See MLUDC Chapter 15.250. I. Street design shall meet the street functional classification. 15.705.040 Performance Standards. A. Air Quality. Emissions from combustion and incineration, emissions from sources emitting hazardous air pollutants, and emissions of suspended particles or fugitive dust shall not exceed the standards set forth in Chapter 173-400 WAC, General Regulations for Air Pollution. Where such emissions could be produced as a result of accident or equipment malfunction, safeguards standard for safe operation in the industry shall be taken. Polluted air streams shall be treated with the best available control technology. B. Heat, Glare, and Humidity (Steam). Any activity producing humidity in the form of steam or moist air, or producing heat or glare, shall be carried on in such a manner that the heat, glare, or humidity is not perceptible at or beyond the property line. Artificial lighting shall be hooded or shaded so that direct light of high intensity lamps will not result in objectionable glare. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 5 of 57 C. Odors. Any use producing odors shall implement best available practices and use best available technology so that offensive or obnoxious odors shall not be perceptible to a person of normal sensitivity at or beyond the property line. D. Vibration. Every use shall be so operated that the ground vibration inherently and recurrently generated from equipment other than vehicles is not perceptible without instruments at any point beyond the property line. E. Electromagnetic Interference. Electric fields and magnetic fields shall not be created that adversely affect the public health, safety, and welfare, including but not limited to interference with the normal operation of equipment or instruments or normal radio, telephone, or television reception from off the premises where the activity is conducted. This section does not apply to telecommunication facilities which are regulated by the FCC under the Federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 or its successor. F. Noise. Noise within the commercial and industrial zones must not exceed the maximum permissible noise levels set forth in WAC 173-60-040. G. Fire and Explosive Hazard. The manufacture, use, processing, or storage of flammable liquids, gases, or solids shall be in compliance with the State Fire Code, the State Building Code, National Fire Protection Association standards, and any other state or nationally recognized standards that may apply to the particular use, building, or process. H. Health Regulations. All uses must be in compliance with all current health regulations. I. State Building Code, State Fire Code, State Mechanical Code, and State Plumbing Code Requirements. All uses must be in compliance with the applicable requirements of the State Building Code, the State Fire Code, the State Mechanical Code, and the State Plumbing Code except as may be provided in this Chapter. J. Outside Storage. Outside storage is permitted in C-1A and C-2 zones when conducted in conjunction with the principal use which is in an enclosed adjoining building. Outside storage is prohibited in the other commercial zones. K. Fences and Walls. All fences and walls will require a fence permit to be issued by the Building Official prior to construction or installation. Electric and barbed wire fences are prohibited, except that security fences containing barbed wire may be permitted subject to review by the Building Official regarding the safety of such a fence. All applications for permits to construct or install fences or walls shall be reviewed by the Building Official and City Engineer for vehicular and pedestrian safety. Additional information about fences is contained in MLUDC Chapter 15.725. L. Stormwater and Drainage. 1. Each use shall provide for approved on-site or off-site detention or control of excess stormwater runoff or drainage resulting from the use. No use shall cause downstream property owners to receive stormwater runoff at a higher peak flow than would have resulted from the same event had the use or improvement not been present. 2. Stormwater shall comply with the Stormwater Management Manual for Eastern Washington. 3. Stormwater runoff or drainage shall be controlled and contained on site except where adequate off-site storm drainage systems are available. Stormwater runoff Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 6 of 57 and/or drainage resulting from a use must be controlled so that water will not flow onto a public sidewalk or onto adjacent property unless approved by the City Engineer or Building Official. Drainage into City storm sewer or onto a City street must be approved by the City Engineer. 15.705.050 Pedestrian Standards. The pedestrian standards encourage a safe, attractive, and usable pedestrian circulation system in all developments. They ensure a direct pedestrian connection between the street and buildings on the site, and between buildings and other activities within the site. In addition, they provide for connections between adjacent sites, where feasible A. Improvements Required. An on-site pedestrian circulation system shall be provided. The system shall meet all standards of this section. B. Connection to the Street. The system shall connect all adjacent streets to the main entrance. One (1) of the connections should be no longer than the straight-line distance from the entrance to the closest sidewalk. It may not be more than twenty feet (20’) longer or one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the straight-line distance, whichever is less. C. Connection to Neighboring Uses. The system shall connect to all adjacent properties. The connections shall extend to the property line and connect to paths or sidewalks on neighboring properties or to the likely location of connections on those properties. When no connections exist on a neighboring property and extending a connection would create a safety hazard or it is not possible to determine the likely location of future connections on that property, the City of Moses Lake may enter into a legally binding agreement with the owner of the property being developed to construct the connection to the neighboring use when the property on which the use is located develops or redevelops. This agreement shall run with the land and be recorded in the Grant County Auditor’s Office. D. Internal Connections. The system shall connect all buildings on the site and provide connections to other areas of the site, such as parking areas, bicycle parking, recreational areas, common outdoor areas, and any pedestrian amenities E. Lighting. The on-site pedestrian circulation system shall be lighted to an intensity where the system can be used at night by employees, residents, and customers. Lighting should be at a height appropriate for a pedestrian pathway system. F. Materials. 1. The circulation system shall be paved and be at least five feet (5’) wide. 2. Where the system crosses driveways, parking areas, and loading areas, the system shall be clearly identifiable through the use of elevation changes, speed bumps, a different paving material, or other equally effective methods. Striping does not meet this requirement. 3. Where the system is parallel and adjacent to an auto travel lane, the system shall be a raised path or be separated from the auto travel lane by a raised curb, bollards, landscaping, or another physical barrier. If a raised path is used, the ends of the raised portions shall be equipped with curb ramp. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 7 of 57 15.705.060 Shoreline Master Program. All property developed within two hundred feet (200’) of the high water line of Moses Lake or its associated wetlands, and any associated uses relying on the shoreline for such use, shall conform with the City’s Shoreline Management Plan. 15.705.070 Community Street and Utility Standards and City Design Standards. Uses must be in compliance with Chapter 12 of the City Community Street and Utility Standards and City Design Standards in effect at the time of issuance of a building permit except that enlargement, alteration, replacement, or repair must be to current City standards. 15.705.080 Structures over Easements or Right-of-Way. No building or structure shall be constructed or placed over dedicated right-of-way or over a public utility or municipal easement, except as specifically allowed in other sections of the MLUDC. This section shall not be construed to prohibit permitted signage. In commercial zones, awnings, roof overhangs, and similar structures may project over City sidewalk when attached to buildings sited on property line and fronting on a City street subject to review and approval by the Director and Building Official. 15.705.090 Maintenance of Lots. Lots shall be maintained so as to not create a fire hazard and shall be free of litter, debris, garbage, unsightly material, or weeds. 15.705.100 Maintenance of City Right-of-Way. The property owner shall be responsible for the maintenance of City right-of-way from the back side of the curb, including but not limited to sidewalks, planter strips, driveways, and landscaping. Where there is no curb, the property owner shall be responsible for the maintenance from the edge of asphalt, back of ditch, or traveled way. 15.705.110 Issuance of a Business License or a Certificate of Occupancy. No certificate of occupancy or business license may be issued by the City until the premises in question have been inspected and found by the Building Official to be in compliance with the provisions and requirements of the MLUDC and MLMC. 15.705.120 Vehicle Maintenance. There shall be no maintenance of vehicles on City rights-of-way. Oil and gasoline shall not be dumped on paved City streets or into catch basins or storm sewers. 15.705.130 General Residential Performance Standard. Uses within the residential zones shall not inflict upon adjacent property smoke, dirt, dust, glare, odors, steam, vibration, noise, electrical interference, or excessive hazard. Noise in the residential zones shall not exceed the standards set forth in MLMC Chapter 8.28. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 8 of 57 Chapter 15.710 PROJECT DESIGN STANDARDS Sections: 15.710.010 Applicability. 15.710.020 Site Design. 15.710.030 Outdoor Spaces. 15.710.050 Stormwater Management Manual for Eastern Washington. 15.710.060 Industrial Zoning Districts Standards. 15.710.070 Commercial Zone – Noise. 15.710.010 Applicability. A. Development Types to be Reviewed. Project design standards, review, and approval is required prior to the location, occupancy, or use of any: 1. Commercial project, building, or facility; 2. Industrial project, building, or facility; or 3. Any multi-family residential use or structure containing four or more dwelling units. B. When Reviewed. Project design review shall apply to all new development, expansions, or site improvements that will change the physical conditions of a site. Review shall be required and processed along with the appropriate land use permit or associated with a building permit application. This review must be approved prior to issuance of a building permit. C. Only Reviewing Project Design. Project design review is not intended to review and determine the appropriateness of a given use on a particular site. D. Project Requirements. Any project level requirement found within the MLUDC shall be applied herein. 15.710.020 Site Design. A. Site Design. The following design elements shall be applied to all projects: 1. Site Design Layout. a. Sites shall be developed in a coordinated manner to complement the natural topography and drainage, and adjacent structures through building placement, architecture, and size/mass. b. Whenever possible, buildings on the same site shall be designed to enhance safe and convenient pedestrian access between buildings including plazas, courtyards, pocket parks, and other pedestrian use areas connected by clearly marked walkways. c. Where appropriate, sites shall incorporate transit-compatible designs. “Transit compatible” means designs that are pedestrian oriented, provide safe and convenient access to transit facilities, and foster efficient transit service. d. Where appropriate, sites shall be designed to provide vehicular and pedestrian connections to adjacent sites. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 9 of 57 e. Landscaping shall make use of minimizing the need for water or irrigation through xeriscape design, native plan species, and minimizing turf and irrigated areas to appropriate levels for the site (such as establishing trees as an example). 2. Tree Preservation. a. Project design shall maximize the preservation of existing significant tree stands and significant individual trees, especially on slopes, street frontages, and on the perimeter of the site. b. Project design shall incorporate existing natural and native vegetation into the site design wherever possible. 3. Setback Landscaping. Landscaping shall comply with MLUDC Chapter 15.720. a. Setback areas are to be landscaped and covered with live plant materials. b. Setback landscaping may include low impact development stormwater management facilities that are not fenced and can be designed to integrate vegetation appropriately into the setback’s landscape area. 4. On-site Pedestrian Circulation. a. Pathways between dwelling units and the street are required. Such pathways shall make a direct connection to the street. b. The pedestrian circulation system shall connect entrances on the site. Pedestrian connections to other areas of the site, such as parking areas, recreational areas, common open space, and other amenities shall be required. Pedestrian pathways may be located within setback landscaping. c. Pedestrian pathways shall be clearly defined and designed to be separated from driveways and parking areas, through the use of raised curbs, elevation changes, bollards, landscaping, different paving materials, and/or other similar treatments. Striping does not meet this requirement. 5. On-Site Vehicular Circulation, Parking, and Bicycle Facilities. a. Vehicular access points from public roads or primary private drives shall be limited, by sharing driveways and linking parking lots between adjacent uses. b. On-site primary vehicular circulation drives shall be separated and provide minimal vehicular conflict with parking areas. c. Parking garages should be designed and sited to complement, not dominate, the streetscape and shall be screened when visible from public streets. Above- grade parking garages shall be designed to incorporate architectural elements that complement the adjacent buildings. d. Bicycle racks shall be located near the entrances to each commercial, multi- family or mixed use buildings, and to the main features of each recreational amenity. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 10 of 57 B. Screening Standards. Mechanical equipment, trash and recycling dumpsters, and any outdoor related equipment shall be screened from abutting properties, public rights-of- way, and open space with a combination of fencing and landscaping. Screening shall be complementary to the materials and colors of the primary structure(s) and shall be of a height appropriate to reduce the appearance of the materials being screened. See MLUDC Chapter 15.725. 15.710.030 Outdoor Spaces. A. Design and locate outdoor spaces and gateways as outlined in the Comprehensive Plan and Sub-Area Plans. 1. All outdoor spaces shall be ADA and handicapped-accessible; 2. Outdoor spaces will be evaluated with the following considerations: a. Orientation. Orient to sunlight to the maximum extent feasible and provide good physical and visual access to the sidewalk or walkway, so that the space is perceived as an extension of the sidewalk. b. Dimensions. Size is adequate for seating, planting, etc., but not so large as to appear barren and uninviting. c. Seating. Provide seating at comfortable height and depth, and appropriate arrangement appropriate for both single and group users. d. Pavement. Use nonglare, nonslip, and safe surface materials. e. Trees and Planting. Consider provision for shade and sun. Use to create space and define human scale. Provide protection from wind. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 11 of 57 f. Amenities. Use pedestrian-scaled lighting, fountains or other water features, litter receptacles and sheltered waiting areas. g. Physical Access. Ensure ready physical as well as visual access with special attention to elevation differences. h. Enclosure. Use landscaping or structure to provide a sense of enclosure, while ensuring visual access for safety; B. Recognize the transportation and recreation uses to provide pedestrian and bicycle connections from private development adjacent to the corridor, when appropriate, to preserve the opportunity for future multi-modal transportation access. Site design will be evaluated with connectivity of trails, sidewalks, and bike routes in mind. 15.710.050 Stormwater Management Manual for Eastern Washington. All projects shall comply with the current Stormwater Management Manual for Eastern Washington. 15.710.060 Industrial Zoning Districts Standards. A. Air Quality. Air emissions shall meet applicable state and federal regulations, including but not limited to Title 173 WAC - Department of Ecology, and Title 296 WAC – Department of Labor and Industries. Where emissions could be released as a result of accident or equipment malfunction, standard safeguards for safe operation of the industry involved shall be taken. Air emissions can include but are not limited to smoke, dust, particulate matter, odor, or gas/vapor. B. Odors. Any use producing odors shall implement best available practices and use best available technology so that offensive or obnoxious odor shall not be perceptible to a person of normal sensitivity at or beyond the property line. Any use producing odors shall implement best available practices and use best available technology so that offensive or obnoxious odors shall not be perceptible to a person of normal sensitivity at or beyond the Industrial Zone boundary line. C. Heat and Humidity. Any use or activity producing heat or humidity in the form of steam or moist air shall be carried on in such a manner that the heat or humidity is not perceptible at or beyond the property line. D. Glare. Any activity producing glare shall be carried on in such a manner that the glare is not perceptible at or beyond the property line. Building and infrastructure materials with high reflectivity of light shall not be used or shall receive surface treatments to prevent the reflection of light or glare onto areas within and surrounding Industrial Zones. Artificial lighting shall be hooded or shaded so that direct light of high intensity lamps will not result in glare when viewed from public streets or neighboring properties. E. Vibrations. Every use shall be so operated that any air or ground vibration recurrently generated from equipment other than vehicles is not perceptible without instruments at any point on or beyond the property line. F. Hazardous Materials. The manufacture, use, processing or storage of hazardous materials or substances shall be permitted in accordance with the regulations of the State Building Code, State Fire Code, the National Fire Protection Association standards Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 12 of 57 as set forth in Titles 51 WAC, Chapter 296-843 WAC, Chapters 19.27 and 35.21 RCW, and compliance with any other state or nationally recognized standards that may apply to the particular use, building, or process. G. Industrial Wastes. The storage, processing, or disposal of dangerous or hazardous waste shall be subject to the regulations of Title 173 WAC - Department of Ecology and Title 296 WAC – Department of Labor and Industries. H. Flammable and Explosive Hazards. The manufacture, use, processing, storage, and disposal of flammable liquids or materials that produce or are innately flammable or explosive substances shall be subject to the regulations of the State Building Code, State Fire Code, the National Fire Protection Association standards as set forth in Titles 51 WAC, Chapter 296-843 WAC, Chapters 19.27 and 35.21 RCW, and compliance with any other state or nationally recognized standards that may apply to the particular use, building, or process. I. Electromagnetic Interference. Electric fields and magnetic fields shall not be created that adversely affect the public health, safety, and welfare, including but not limited to interference with the normal operation of equipment or instruments or normal radio, telephone, or television reception from off the premises where the activity is conducted. This section does not apply to telecommunication facilities which are regulated by the FCC under the Federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 or its successor. J. Noise. Noise emanating from a use or activity within an industrial zone which exceeds the maximum permissible noise levels set forth in WAC 173-60-040 and this Chapter shall not be permitted. Table 15.710.060 – Maximum Permissible Environmental Noise Levels from a Noise Source in an Industrial Zone (Chapter 173-60 WAC) Property Receiving Noise by Zone Maximum Noise Level Residential* 60 dBA Commercial 65 dBA Industrial 70 dBA *Between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. the noise limitations shall be reduced by 10 dBA for receiving property in residential zones. At any hour of the day or night the applicable noise limitations may be exceeded for any receiving property by no more than: 1. 5 dBA for a total of 15 minutes in any 1-hour period 2. 10 dBA for a total of 5 minutes in any 1-hour period 3. 15 dBA for a total of 1.5 minutes in any 1-hour period Exemptions to the maximum permissible noise levels cited in this Chapter shall be as enumerated in WAC 173-60-050, Maximum Environmental Noise Levels Exemptions. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 13 of 57 K. Additional Requirements. Additional requirements are found in other Chapters of the Municipal Code, other adopted City regulations, and applicable State and Federal agency regulations, including but not limited to the following: 1. Washington State Building Code, Title 51 WAC, 2. Chapters 19.27 and 35.21 RCW, including to the State Building Code, State Fire Code, State Mechanical Code, and State Plumbing Code. 3. Washington State Department of Ecology, Title 173 WAC. 4. Washington State Public Health and Safety, Title 70 RCW. 5. Washington State Environmental Health and Safety, Title 70A RCW. 6. Washington State Department of Labor and Industries, Title 296 WAC. 7. Washington State Labor Regulations, Title 49 RCW. 8. Washington State Public Highways and Transportation, Title 47 RCW 15.710.070 Commercial Zone – Noise. Noise emanating from a use or activity within a commercial zone which exceeds the maximum permissible noise levels set forth in WAC 173-60-040 and this Chapter shall not be permitted. Table 15.710.070 – Maximum Permissible Environmental Noise Levels from a Noise Source in an Commercial Zone (Chapter 173-60 WAC) Property Receiving Noise by Zone Maximum Noise Level Residential* 57 dBA Commercial 60 dBA Industrial 65 dBA *Between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. the noise limitations shall be reduced by 10 dBA for receiving property in residential zones. At any hour of the day or night the applicable noise limitations may be exceeded for any receiving property by no more than: 4. 5 dBA for a total of 15 minutes in any 1-hour period 5. 10 dBA for a total of 5 minutes in any 1-hour period 6. 15 dBA for a total of 1.5 minutes in any 1-hour period Exemptions to the maximum permissible noise levels cited in this Chapter shall be as enumerated in WAC 173-60-050, Maximum Environmental Noise Levels Exemptions. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 14 of 57 Chapter 15.715 PARKING Sections: 15.715.010 Applicability. 15.715.020 General Standards. 15.715.030 Specific Parking Requirements. 15.715.040 Location of Parking Area. 15.715.050 Bicycle Facilities Standards. 15.715.060 Specific Loading Requirements. 15.715.070 ADA Accessibility 15.715.080 Development and Maintenance. 15.715.090 On-Site Drainage for Parking Lots. 15.715.100 Waivers and Exceptions. 15.715.110 Electric Vehicle Charging Station Standards. 15.715.010 Applicability. A. Applicability. Unless exempt as provided herein, the requirements of this Chapter shall apply to all of the following: 1. New development. 2. Replacement or improvement of more than forty-five percent (45%) of existing impervious surfaces on a developed site. 3. A twenty-five percent (25%) or greater expansion of an existing parking lot. 4. Any addition, remodel, alteration, or repair of a structure that increases the gross floor area by more than seventy-five percent (75%) or where the cost of the addition, remodel, alteration, or repair exceeds seventy-five percent (75%) of the existing assessed value of the structure. 5. Change of occupancy (per the Building Code). B. Exceptions. 1. No off-street parking shall be required for home occupations or for businesses located within the C-1 Central Business District and the C-1A Transitional Commercial Zone. 2. Preservation and Maintenance. The following parking area maintenance practices are exempt from the requirements of this Chapter: a. Pothole and square cut patching. b. Crack sealing. c. Vegetation maintenance. d. Overlaying existing asphalt or concrete pavement with bituminous surface treatment (BST or “chip seal”). 15.715.020 General Standards. A. Access and Capacity. The parking and/or loading areas shall have reasonable access and a capacity according to the use of the property listed in the following sections. Where a use is not listed, the Director shall determine the required parking and/or loading space based on similar uses for which the requirements are specified or based on an analysis of likely parking needs. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 15 of 57 B. Wheel or Bumper Stops. Wheel or bumper stops shall be required to prevent vehicles from overhanging walkways, property lines, or other limits of a parking facility and to prevent damage to landscaping. C. Use of Streets. Except for single family dwelling, duplex or triplex unit driveways, access or aisles shall be designed in a manner which does not permit backing movements or other maneuvering within or onto a street other than an alley. D. Aisles. Aisle width shall be a minimum of twenty-four feet (24’) for two way traffic and, as applicable, meet fire lane standards. One way traffic aisle can be reduced in width upon approval by the Fire Department. E. Drive Through Windows. Drive through windows shall have a stacking lane of a minimum of one hundred twenty feet (120’) and shall be designed to not block access, parking aisles, or fire lanes. F. Landscaping. Parking lot landscaping shall comply with MLUDC Chapter 15.720, Landscaping. G. Carpool Parking. For industrial, commercial, and institutional uses where there are more than fifty (50) parking spaces on the site, the following standards must be met: 1. Five (5) spaces or five percent (5%) of the parking spaces on the site, whichever is less, must be reserved for carpool use. More spaces may be provided, but are not required. 2. Signs must be posted, or painted within the spaces, indicating that these spaces are reserved for carpool use. H. Litter Receptacles. All off-street parking areas serving retail uses and restaurants shall provide at least one (1) outdoor litter receptacle within the parking area or at the building entrance. One (1) additional outdoor litter receptacle shall be provided within the parking area or at the building entrance for each seventy-five (75) parking spaces located on the site. I. Parking Space Dimensions. Except for compact car spaces, each parking space shall be no less than nine feet (9’) wide and twenty feet (20’) long. J. Compact Parking Spaces. Ten percent (10%) of the total spaces required may be for compact cars only. These spaces must be designated. Each compact space shall be at least eight feet (8’) wide and sixteen feet (16’) long and shall be clearly identified as a compact car space by painting the word “COMPACT” in capital letters, a minimum of eight inches (8”) high, on the pavement at the base of the parking space and centered between the striping. K. Mixed Occupancy Building. A building that has mixed occupancies shall provide parking for each use as required in MLUDC 15.715.030. 15.715.030 Specific Parking Requirements. Table 15.715.030 – Specific Parking Requirements LAND USE REQUIRED PARKING RESIDENTIAL Duplex 2 per dwelling unit Manufactured home park 2 per dwelling unit plus 5% of total for guest parking Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 16 of 57 Studio and 1-bedroom apartment 1 per unit, plus 5% of total for guests Multi-family 2 per unit for 2 or more bedrooms plus 2% of total for guests. Senior citizen dwellings/apartments 0.5 per unit Single-family homes (including manufactured homes) 2 per unit RETAIL BUSINESS Appliance and furniture sales/service 1 per 1,000 square feet of display area Automobile sales/rentals 1 per 400 gross square feet of inside display area, 1 per 2,000 gross square feet of outside display area Building supply and home improvement 1 per 1,000 gross square feet of warehouse area Convenience store 1 per 350 gross square feet, plus 2 for every 2.5 seats of on-site seating, but not less than 10. Service area at gas pumps shall not be counted as parking spaces Equipment rental shop 1 per 300 gross square feet of retail, office or shop use, 1 per 1,000 gross square feet of outdoor storage or display area Espresso/latte stand (no seating) 1, plus 1 per employee Greenhouse/nursery 1 per 400 gross square feet of indoor retail, 1 per 1,000 gross square feet of outdoor display or storage area Landscape materials sales 3 plus 1 per employee Motor vehicle parts sales/service 1 per 300 gross square feet Print shop 1 per 400 gross square feet Recreational vehicle sales and service 1 per 3,000 gross square feet of display area Restaurant 1 per 100 gross square feet, except when located in a shopping center Retail, e.g., grocery store, drug store, shoe store, etc. 1 per 250 gross square feet Shopping centers 4.5 per 1,000 square feet of gross leasable area (GLA) for centers having GLA less than 400,000 gross square feet, and 5 per 1,000 gross feet of GLA for centers having a GLA over 400,000 gross square feet Tavern 1 per 4 seats SERVICE Animal clinic/veterinary 1 per 250 square feet of gross indoor floor area Assisted living facility 1 per 4 residents, plus 1 per staff on largest shift Automobile/truck/RV/motorcycle service, painting, repair, body, and fender work 1 per 300 gross square feet of building minus service bays, plus 2 per service bay Banks, savings and loan, etc. 2.5 per 1,000 gross square feet Barber shop and beauty shops 2 per station Carpenter shop 1 per 600 gross square feet Carwash 1 per employee, 2 spaces per stall for drying purposes Day care, child and adult 1 per employee, plus 1 per 10 children or adults Dry cleaning, linen, laundry 1 per 500 square feet, plus 1 per employee Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 17 of 57 Funeral home 1 per 4 seats or 8 lineal feet of bench in chapel area Hospital 1 per 4 patient beds, plus 1 space per doctor, plus 1 per each 3 additional employees Hotel/motel 1 per guest room, plus 1 per shift employee for the largest shift Kennel/animal boarding/shelter 3, plus 1 per shift employee Laboratories 1 per 600 gross square feet Medical/dental clinic 1 per each doctor or dentist, plus 1 per 250 gross square feet Office, professional and general 1 per 250 gross square feet Recreational vehicle park/campground 1 per RV site/campsite, 1 per employee INDUSTRIAL Industrial warehouses, freight terminals, manufacturing, etc. 1 per shift employee on the maximum shift Brewery, winery and/or distillery 1 per shift employee on the maximum shift, plus 1 per 4 seats in any tasting room or other visitor facility Showroom (appurtenant to industrial use) 1 per 500 gross square feet of display area PUBLIC AND SEMI-PUBLIC Auditorium, theaters, stadium 1 per 4 fixed seats or 8 lineal feet of bench seating Church or other place of worship 1 per 4 seats or 8 lineal feet of bench seating College or university 1 per 2 students, plus 1 per employee Community hall, club or lodge 1 per 200 gross square feet Dance, exhibition and assembly halls 1 per 75 square feet of gross floor area of main assembly room Golf course 2 per hole Golf driving range/training center 2 per designated driving station on driving range and 1 per 500 square feet of putting/chipping green Libraries 1 per 400 square feet of gross floor area Sports field 20 per acre of site Swimming pool 1 per 100 gross square feet of water surface area Tennis, racquetball and similar courts 2 per court Exercise facility/gym athletic club 1 per 100 gross square feet Fire, police station 1 space per employee on the maximum shift Post office, postal center 1 per 200 gross square feet of public area, plus 1 per employee Racetrack 1 per each 4 fixed seats or 8 lineal feet of bench seating School, training/learning, professional, vocational and trade 1 per 2 students Schools, public and private preschool 1.5 per teacher Schools, public and private K through 8 1 per teacher, plus 1 per other employees Schools, public and private 9 through 12 1 per 2 students, plus 1 per shift employee Transit center 1 per 200 gross square feet Skating rink 1 per 200 gross square feet Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 18 of 57 15.715.040 Location of Parking Area. A. Residential. Required parking space shall be located adjacent to the residence. B. Commercial, Industrial, Public, and Institutional. Required parking shall be on site or within three hundred feet (300’) of the building, unless authorized by the Director. Businesses located within a C-1 Central Business District and C-1A Commercial Transitional Zone shall be exempt from the parking requirement. 15.715.050 Bicycle Facilities Standards. A. Bicycle Parking Spaces. Off-street parking areas shall contain at least one (1) bicycle parking space for every twelve (12) spaces required for motor vehicles except as follows: 1. If there are less than twelve (12) parking spaces, no bicycle facilities are required. 2. The Director may reduce bike parking facilities when it is demonstrated that bicycle activity is unlikely to occur at that location. 3. The Director may require additional spaces when it is determined that the use or its location will generate a high volume of bicycle activity. Such a determination will include but not be limited to the following uses: a. Park/playfield. b. Library/museum/arboretum. c. Elementary/secondary school. d. Sports club. e. Retail business (when located along a developed bicycle trail or designated bicycle route). B. Location of Bicycle Parking. All bicycle parking shall be located on the ground level and within one hundred feet (100’) of the building entrance, shall be located in safe, visible areas (i.e., in view of windows, street, or sidewalk) that do not impede pedestrian or vehicle traffic flow, and shall be well lit for nighttime use. In the case of multiple businesses, bicycle parking shall be placed in multiple locations or near the center of the development. Covered bicycle parking is optional but encouraged. See Diagram 1. C. Required Improvements. Bicycle parking shall be improved in accordance with the following requirements: 1. Bicycle racks shall enable a U-lock to lock both the frame of the bicycle and bicycle tire to the bicycle rack. 2. Bicycle racks shall support the frame of the bicycle in at least two (2) places. 3. Bicycle parking shall not encroach upon the five foot (5’) sidewalk or the required pedestrian connection. 4. Bicycle parking shall be secured with tamper-proof screws or be cast in place upon concrete. 5. Bicycle racks shall be a “U” bike rack. See Diagram 2. 6. Variations may be allowed if it the intent of subsections (C)(1) through (C)(4) of this section are met. Requests may be submitted to the Department. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 19 of 57 15.715.060 Specific Loading Requirements. A. General Loading Requirements. Other than those listed in subsection B of this section, commercial, industrial, and public utility uses shall provide truck loading and unloading space as follows: Table 15.715.060(A) General Loading Requirements Square Feet of Floor Area No. of Spaces Required Less than 10,000 0 10,000-30,000 1 30,001-100,000 2 100,001 and over 3 B. Special Loading Requirements. Restaurants, office buildings, hotels, motels, hospitals and institutions, schools and colleges, public buildings, recreational or entertainment facilities, and any similar use shall provide off-street truck loading or unloading spaces as follows: Table 15.715.060(B) Special Loading Requirements Square Feet of Floor Area No. of Spaces Required Less than 30,000 1 30,001-100,000 2 100,001 and over 3 C. Size of Loading Space. A loading space shall consist of a space not less than ten feet (10’) wide, thirty-five feet (35’) long, and a height clearance of fourteen feet (14’). Where vehicles generally used for loading and unloading exceed these dimensions, the required length of these spaces shall be increased. The Building Official may waive the height requirement upon receipt of evidence that such height is unnecessary. D. Location of Loading Area. The required off-street loading area shall be located on the same lot with the use it is intended to serve. E. Restriction on Use. Off-street parking areas used to fulfill the requirements of this title shall not be used for loading and unloading operations except during periods of the day when not required to serve parking needs. 15.715.070 ADA Accessibility. The type and number of Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliant parking spaces shall be subject to applicable state law, and each ADA parking space shall be considered as one (1) parking space for the purposes of calculating required parking 15.715.080 Development and Maintenance. A. Parking Improvements. Every parcel of land hereafter used for parking purposes shall be developed and permanently maintained in accordance with the following requirements: 1. Surfacing. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 20 of 57 a. Parking areas shall be surfaced with an asphaltic or cement binder pavement or other approved material. Parking areas shall be built on a suitable base so as to provide a durable and dustless surface and shall be so graded and drained as to properly dispose of all surface water on site. b. Asphalt, brick, concrete paving, and interlocking paving blocks, including semi- pervious systems that retain space for vegetation, are acceptable paving materials. c. All parking surfaces shall be maintained in sound condition free of weeds, dust, trash, debris, potholes, and other hazards. d. Any parking lot adjacent to an existing paved street shall be maintained in hard surface paving, including parking spaces, access aisles, and all areas to be driven on by vehicles. 2. Striping. a. All required stalls, aisles, loading zones, fire lanes, and no parking areas shall be striped or otherwise designated to provide for the safe loading, unloading, parking, and storage of vehicles. b. Single-family residential and two (2) family residential are exempt from striping requirement. 3. Parking Lot Lighting. Any lighting used to illuminate a parking lot shall be directed and shielded as to not illuminate surrounding properties. Light standards shall not exceed eighteen feet (18’) in height measured from grade to the highest point of the equipment. In instances where it can be established that additional height is required for health and safety reasons, an additional five feet (5’) in height is allowed, subject to review and approval by the Building Official. B. Low Impact Development (LID). LID is encouraged for all parking areas. In parking lot design, this can be achieved with the use of the following design features: 1. Pervious paving material. 2 Flat curbing to encourage stormwater flows to drainage facilities. 3. Vegetative islands and perimeter buffers, planted with native plant species tolerant of and adapted to the amount of moisture anticipated in the island or buffer. 4. Vegetated islands and medians located below grade so water will flow to them. 5. Vegetated, natural drainage swales. 6. Creation of wetland cells planted with appropriate plant species and strategically located to capture runoff. 7. Grading across the lot to encourage runoff flows to drainage areas. 15.715.090 On-Site Drainage for Parking Lots. A. Best Management Practices. It is the intent of these regulations to require the use of best management practices (BMPs) per the Eastern Washington Stormwater Manual to minimize, treat, prevent and/or reduce degradation of water quality and flooding potential due to stormwater runoff from parking. The stormwater management system shall be designed, constructed, and maintained with BMPs to minimize runoff volumes, prevent flooding, reduce soil erosion, protect water quality, maintain or improve wildlife habitat, and retain all stormwater on site pursuant to MLMC Section 13.35.030. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 21 of 57 B. Stormwater Infiltration. Infiltration of stormwater shall be accommodated to the extent possible through limitation of land disturbance and grade changes, retention of existing natural drainage areas and wetlands, and use or creation of vegetated islands, vegetated medians, and vegetated perimeter buffer strips. C. Drainage Patterns. Natural drainage patterns shall be maintained to the extent practicable. The Applicant must demonstrate, through information provided on and in association with the proposed site plan, the existing and proposed drainage patterns and calculated flows. D. Impervious Surface Reduction. Measures that shall be considered to reduce the amount of impervious surfaces in all proposed parking lots include: 1. Provide pervious parking stall surfaces. 2. Provide pervious overflow parking. 3. Provide pervious snow-storage space. 4. Conserve existing natural areas, including trees, on site. 15.715.100 Waivers and Exceptions. A. Bicycle Parking. The Director may reduce bicycle parking facilities for patrons when it is demonstrated that bicycle activity is unlikely to occur at that location, provided bike rack parking is not completely eliminated. B. Minimum Parking Spaces. An Applicant may request a modification of the minimum required number of parking spaces by proving that parking demand can be met with reduced parking. In such cases, the Director may approve a reduction of up to fifty percent (50%) of the minimum required number of spaces. C. Overflow Parking. Overflow parking areas and event-parking areas may use turf or other pervious surfaces. “Overflow parking” shall be defined as off-street parking in excess of the minimum required by this Chapter, not used more than fifteen (15) times a year. All parking areas for which paving is waived shall meet the minimum requirements of the State Building Code. All parking areas shall be constructed with proper drainage. D. Existing Building. When an existing building is occupied by a new use which would require greater parking or loading space than is provided, the Director may waive the additional parking requirement provided the Director finds existing development renders compliance with the requirement impractical. 15.715.110 Electric Vehicle Charging Station Standards. A. Parking spaces designated for electric vehicle charging shall be included in the calculation of the number of off-street parking spaces provided pursuant to this Chapter. B. Each electric vehicle charging station space shall be posted with signage indicating the space is for electric vehicle charging purposes. Signage should include identifying voltage and amperage levels, time of use, fees, safety or other information. See examples below of typical signage: Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 22 of 57 C. Installation of wayfinding signs should be conveniently located to effectively guide motorists to the charging station space(s). Such signs shall comply with this sign standards. D. Where charging station equipment is provided adjacent to a pedestrian circulation area, such as a sidewalk or accessible route to the building entrance, charging equipment shall be located so as not to interfere with accessibility requirements of WAC 51-50-005, as amended. E. Alternative Parking Bonus. The addition and/or inclusion of electric vehicle parking spaces will receive a bonus of a reduction of 20% from the overall parking requirement. F. Battery exchange stations shall store all batteries in an enclosed building. No outdoor storage is permitted. All batteries that are beyond their useful life shall be recycled or disposed of in accordance with requirements established by the State Department of Ecology, State Department of Transportation, and the Environmental Protection Agency. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 23 of 57 Chapter 15.720 LANDSCAPING AND BUFFERING Sections: 15.720.020 010 Applicability. 15.720.020 General Landscaping Requirements. 15.720.030 Residential Landscaping. 15.720.030 040 Buffer Landscaping. 15.720.040 050 Parking Lot Landscaping. 15.720.050 060 Water Conservation. 15.720.070 Approval of Landscape Plan and Installation of Landscaping. 15.720.080 Prohibited Plants. 15.720.010 Applicability. The provisions of this Chapter regarding landscaping shall apply to all new and rehabilitated landscaping for: A. New Development. 1. Commercial and industrial development projects. 2. Developer-installed landscaping in multi-family and single-family residential projects.Residential subdivision projects. 3. Residential development in any zoning classification, with the exception of building permit applications for single-family homes and their accessory uses.New residential construction as part of a subdivision. Residential dwelling unit that revises, maintains or alters existing landscaping is exempt. 4. Public agency projects. 5. Installation of a new parking lot or structure that includes twenty (20) or more parking stalls. B. Expansions and Enlargements. 1. The gross floor area of an existing structure is expanded or enlarged by fifty50 percent (50%) or more, with the exception of single family homes and ADU additions; or. 2. There is a change of use of the existing building that requires an increase of off- street parking by 50 fifty percent (50%) or more.; or 15.720.020 General Landscaping Requirements. A. Landscape Required. A landscape plan with designed landscaped areas shall be submitted as a part of all development applications where landscaping, buffering, or screening is required. 1. All submitted landscape plans shall meet the minimum standards as outlined in this Chapter and shall include the following elements:. a. Name and address or location of project. b. Date of the plan. c. North arrow and scale (standard engineering scale, 1" = 50' or larger). d. All property lines, rights-of-way, streets, walks, vehicular drives, parking lots, curbing, existing and proposed structures, building entrances, overhead and Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 24 of 57 underground utilities, freestanding lights, service or loading areas, signs, open spaces, plazas, and recreation amenities, with materials noted. e. Proposed location of all trees, shrubs, ground cover, and any proposed or existing physical elements, such as fencing, walls, curbing, or benches. f. A legend which shows symbols and types of plant and a plant schedule which indicates the scientific and common names, quantities, spacing, and sizes at planting and maturity for all plants in the landscape plan. g. Location and details of irrigation system. The source of water and type of irrigation system shall be noted. i. Location and dimensions of any Critical Areas. j. A calculation of the square footage of landscaping proposed. l. Such other submissions consistent with this Chapter as may be required by the Department. 2. A landscape plan shall be prepared by a person experienced in the selection and installation of plants. For multifamily projects with five (5) or more units and non- residential projects with more than twenty thousand (20,000) square feet of gross floor area, the landscape plan shall be prepared by one of the following: licensed landscape architect, or Certified Professional Horticulturalist. Landscape and irrigation plans shall be prepared by a certified landscape architect, Washington State certified nursery professional, Washington State certified landscaper, or other qualified person with experience in landscape design as approved by the Director. Landscaping plans for existing single family dwelling units not associated with subdivision approved landscaping are exempt from this requirement. 3. The owner and occupant of the property are jointly and severally responsible for maintaining or assuring the ongoing maintenance of installed landscaping so that landscaping continues to thrive. 43. Required landscape and buffer areas shall be designed to serve as stormwater management areas to the maximum extent practicable and consistent with their required locations and vegetation. B. Alternative Landscape Design. The Director may approve modifications to the standards and designs set out in the Chapter if it provides equivalent means of achieving the intent of this Chapter or is consistent with the surrounding landscaping and meets the following: 1. The use of native and other drought tolerant plants and trees to retain the unique character of Moses Lake’s landscape; 2. Conserving water resources by using sustainable design and maintenance techniques and native and/or adapted plant species that are low water-use and regionally appropriate; 3. Incorporation into storm water retention and infiltration, 4. Design includes heat and glare reduction; 5. Improving the appearance of development to protect and enhance public and private investments and property values; Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 25 of 57 6. Establishing an attractive streetscape that contributes to the character and appearance of the City; and 7. Providing screening to minimize the visual impacts of some types of facilities, structures, and equipment. CB. Maintenance. Property owners and occupants of the property with control over landscaped areas shall be responsible for: 1. Maintaining all landscaping in healthy living conditions. 2. Promptly replacing all dead vegetation with healthy, living plants, in accordance with standard seasonal planting practices. DC. Installation of Required Landscaping. 1. Soil preparation. Soil preparation will be suitable to provide healthy growing conditions for the plants and to encourage water infiltration and penetration per the landscape plans. a. All vegetated materials shall be planted in uncompacted soil. b. If used, weed barriers shall be permeable to optimize stormwater infiltration and prevent runoff. c. Soil amendments (organic material) shall also be added and tilled into the soil to a minimum depth of six (6) inches to increase organic content and improved water retention, unless demonstrated that existing organic material is greater than six (6) inches in depth. 2. Mulch. After completion of new planting, all irrigated non-turf areas shall be covered with a minimum of three (3) inch layer of mulch to retain water, inhibit weed growth, and moderate soil temperature. Non-porous material shall not be placed under the mulch. Permitted mulch must be a material of substantial weight and placed in a manner that will keep it in place. a. All rock mulch must be angular or crushed, clean or washed landscape gravel, and be rocks size of two-inch minus, free of fines, unless authorized by the Director. b. The use of gravel or crusher fines is prohibited as ground cover for areas defined as landscaped areas, except for pathways. c. Pea gravel is not permitted. d. Decorative rock material shall have a depth of at least two and one-half (2.5) times the diameter of the rock material, and be placed completely on top of a weed fabric barrier that allows the permeation of water. Rock material shall not exceed the height of the sidewalk/trail or the top back of curb when placed along a public right-of-way. e. Rock mulch used in planter strips adjacent to a public street with a slope of eight (8%) percent or greater shall be compacted. f. Bark and lava rock mulch are prohibited on slopes of eight (8%) percent or greater and due to weight and erosion concerns. g. Bark mulch shall have a depth of at least two and one-half (2.5) times the diameter of the material and shall be chunky. Chunky mulch resembles the Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 26 of 57 mulch found naturally occurring on forest floors. It is made up of uniform grades of chunky particles that restrict the germination of any wind-borne weed seeds. The optimum chunky mulch has pieces no smaller than one (1) inch with zero fines. h. The final grade of all mulch adjacent to a sidewalk or curb shall be level or slightly below the height of the sidewalk and curb to prevent erosion loss. i. Rock mulch shall not be ED. Irrigation of Landscaping. Where landscaping requires an irrigation system itAny irrigation system shall be installed in a manner that minimizes the use of water and eliminates any runoff of water into public right-of-way. 1. The irrigation system shall not spray or irrigate impervious surfaces, including sidewalks, driveways, driveways, drive aisles, streets, and parking and loading areas. 2. All irrigation systems shall be installed in accordance with the City’s Cross- Connection Control Program. FE. Planting In or Over the Public Right of Way. All planting of vegetated material or installation of any landscaping, buffering, or screening material in the public right of way shall require prior approval of the City, and shall comply with line of sight requirements (sight distance triangle). See MLUDC 15.725.010(C). 1. The property owner and occupants of the property with control over landscaped areas shall be responsible for the maintenance, repairs, or liability for all the landscaping placed in or over the public right of way. 2. Landscaping installed within a right of way shall be selected and located in a manner that will not obstruct street signage. 3. Any trees that overhang a public sidewalk shall be trimmed to maintain a nine (9) foot clearance over the sidewalk. Any trees that overhang a public street shall be trimmed to maintain a twelve (12) foot clearance over the street surface. 4. Any trees that overhang shared use path and/or activity trail shall be trimmed to maintain a ten (10) foot clearance over the path or trail. 5. If landscaping installed in the public right of way requires irrigation, any system proposed shall meet the minimum technical requirements of Subsection EF. GF. Turf Limitations. 1. The use of turf is subject to and limited by the provisions of this subsection. The turf limitations imposed by this section are as follows: Table 15.720.020 – Turf Limitations Zoning District/Use Use of Turf Commercial / Industrial Districts Not permitted in landscaped areas. Public Districts Prohibited for ornamental or decorative purposes, except for schools, parks, and or cemeteries. Residential Districts Limited to a maximum of 30% of Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 27 of 57 (single-family) total yard area (front, rear, or side). Lots with less than 5000 sq ft are limited to a maximum of 50% of total yard area. Residential Districts (multi-family) Limited to a maximum of 30% of landscaped area. 2. The turf limitations contained in this subsection are intended to increase the use of water efficient vegetation. 3. The maximum amount of turf allowable pursuant to Paragraph 1 may be increased proportionally by the percentage of water used for irrigation that comes from a legal and lawful access to alternative water, such as a franchise permit, irrigation water, etc. The use of water for irrigation of turf is only permissible from a non- potable source. HG. Landscaping Materials. Landscaping shall include drought-tolerant and water efficient plant materials consistent with City guidelines and the turf limitations of Subsection GF. 15.720.030 Residential Landscaping. Table 15.720.030 – Residential Landscaping Standards R-1 Landscaping Standards Front Yard(1) Maximum Impervious Groundcover(2)(3) 40% Minimum Front Yard Landscaping(4) 50% R-2 Landscaping Standards Front Yard(1) Maximum Impervious Groundcover(2)(3) 50% Minimum Front Yard Landscaping(4) 50% R-3 Landscaping Standards Front Yard(1) Maximum Impervious Groundcover(2)(3) 40% Minimum Front Yard Landscaping(4) 30% Notes: (1) “Front Yard” is defined in MLUDC 15.105.025. (2) “Impervious Groundcover” is defined in MLUDC 15.105.009. (3) Impervious Groundcover may exceed 50% where required to allow two 9’x20’ parking spaces per principal unit with a 5’ wide walkway. (4) Minimum landscaping may be less than 50% where required to allow two 9’x20’ parking spaces per principal unit with a 5’ wide walkway. 15.720.040 Buffer Landscaping. A. Buffer ZonesLandscaping Required. When adjacent to the uses listed, the subject property shall provide the type and width of landscaping listed in the table below along the entire property line between the subject property and the adjacent use, except for Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 28 of 57 vehicular and pedestrian access points. If a building is located in the buffer area, the landscaping displaced by the building shall be located elsewhere on the site. Table 15.720.040 Buffer Landscaping Adjacent Use Subject Property Use Residential Subdivision Multifamily Manufactured Home Park Commercial Industrial Freeway or Highway Type I 20’ wide Type I 20’ wide Type I 20’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type II 10’ wide Street Frontage Type IV 5’ wide Type IV 5’ wide Type IV 5’ wide Type IV 10’ wide Type IV 20’ wide Residential (1/2 dwelling units) or vacant R-1/R-2 Type II 5’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type I 15’ wide Multifamily or vacant R-3 Type II 10’ wide Type III 5’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type I 15’ wide Manufactured Home Park Type II 10’ wide Type III 5’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type I 15’ wide Commercial or vacant C-1, C-1A, C-2 Type II 10’ wide Type II 5’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type II 10’ wide Industrial or vacant L-I/H-I Type II 10’ wide Type I 5’ wide Type II 10’ wide Type II 10’ wide 1. The minimum buffer landscaping width along the rear and side yards may be reduced to an amount approved by the City, but in no case shall it be less than five feet, if an ornamental wall or fence is constructed in conjunction with the landscaping required. B. Landscape Buffer Types. 1. Type I Landscaping. Type I landscaping is a “full screen” that functions as a visual barrier. This landscaping is typically found adjacent to freeways and between residential and non-residential areas. Type I landscaping shall consist of: a. Primarily evergreen or densely branching deciduous trees and shrubs placed to form a continuous all-season screen at least six feet (6') tall within three (3) years of planting. Trees and shrubs may be offset or staggered, rather than in a single line. Other deciduous trees and shrubs may be incorporated for seasonal interest, provided the screening function of the landscaping is not compromised. Trees and shrubs shall be spaced so that they will touch or overlap at mature size. 2. Type II Landscaping. Type II landscaping is a “filtered screen” that functions as a visual separator between similar uses. This landscaping is typically found between commercial and industrial uses; between differing types of residential development; and to screen industrial uses from the street. Type II landscaping shall consist of: Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 29 of 57 a. A mix of evergreen and deciduous trees and medium and/or large shrubs. Trees and shrubs should be offset or staggered, rather than in a single line. Tree size refers to size at maturity, and should be chosen based on the ability of the site to support the size of tree chosen. Large trees should be spaced forty feet (40') to sixty feet (60') apart, medium trees should be spaced thirty feet (30') to forty- five feet (45') apart, and small trees should be spaced twenty feet (20') to thirty feet (30') apart. The minimum number of trees required shall be determined by dividing the total frontage by the maximum spacing for the size of tree chosen. Any fraction of a tree shall be rounded up to the next whole number. b. Required shrubs must achieve a height of four feet (4') within three (3) years. 3. Type III Landscaping. Type III landscaping is a “see-through buffer” to provide visual relief between compatible uses and to soften the appearance of streets, parking areas, and building facades. This landscaping is typically found along street frontages or between apartment developments. Type III landscaping shall consist of: a. A mix of trees. Tree size refers to size at maturity, and should be chosen based on the ability of the site to support the size of tree chosen. Large trees should be spaced forty feet (40') to sixty feet (60') apart, medium trees should be spaced thirty feet (30') to forty-five feet (45') apart, and small trees should be spaced twenty feet (20') to thirty feet (30') apart. The minimum number of trees required shall be determined by dividing the total frontage by the maximum spacing for the size of tree chosen. Any fraction of a tree shall be rounded up to the next whole number. b. A mix of evergreen and deciduous shrubs. 4. Type IV Street Frontage Landscaping. Type IV landscaping is a “see-through buffer” to provide visual relief and to soften the appearance of streets. Type IV landscaping shall consist primarily of trees and include the following: a. Street trees. Tree size refers to size at maturity, and should be chosen based on the ability of the site to support the size of tree chosen. Large trees should be spaced forty feet (40') to sixty feet (60') apart, medium trees should be spaced thirty feet (30') to forty-five feet (45') apart, and small trees should be spaced twenty feet (20') to thirty feet (30') apart. The minimum number of trees required shall be determined by dividing the total frontage by the maximum spacing for the size of tree chosen. Any fraction of a tree shall be rounded up to the next whole number. Columnar tree varieties shall not be used as street trees. b. Shrubs and/or groundcover. Shrubs shall not exceed a height of four feet (4') at maturity. 5. Exceptions. a. No additional street frontage landscaping shall be required along East Broadway, where the existing trees and turf grass are maintained by the City. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 30 of 57 b. The required landscaping will be turf grass with Armstrong Maple, October Glory Maple, or a Sunburst Locust as the street trees for the following aesthetic corridors: i. SR 171, Broadway Avenue from 1-90 to Highway 17. ii. Wheeler Road from City Limits to Highway 17. iii. Pioneer Way from Wheeler Road to I-90. 1. A perimeter buffer zone consisting of landscape planting and screening shall be provided adjacent to all street rights-of-way and property lines as set forth in Table 15.720.030-1 below. Table 15.720.030-1 – Perimeter Landscape Buffer Widths STANDARD RESIDENTIAL (MULTI-FAMILY) COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL RESIDENTIAL (SINGLE FAMILY) Minimum Depth Adjacent to Right-of-Way 10 feet1 15 feet 15 feet 6 feet Minimum Depth – Interior Lots Lines 6 feet2 8 feet2 8 feet2 0 feet Notes: 1. The distance shall be from tree center, and may be modified for placement of utilities, from street safety signs, hydrants and driveways . 2. When adjacent to or across the street from an existing single family residential use or zoning district, the buffer shall be increased to fifteen (15) feet. 3. When building setbacks are less restrictive, the setbacks shall prevail. 4. Perimeter landscaping is exempt within the sight distance triangle on corner residential lots and where required planter strips are located within the public right of way. 5. Tree boxes are containment systems that include trees as vegetation. They are similar to small bioretention cells and are designed to filter or infiltrate stormwater runoff. Tree boxes typically consist of an engineered soil mix, underdrain, and overflow, and are connected to the storm sewer system or other stormwater treatment system. 6. Landscaping shall be placed street-ward of any fencing and include gates along the fence for access and maintenance of landscaping, except as approved by the Director. 2. Residential dwelling unit lots shall have a maximum of fifty percent (50%) front landscape. 3. Sight distance requirements (sight distance triangle) shall be met. B. Plant Material. The following are spacing requirements for plant material. 1. The standard planting requirement is as set forth in the figure below. Trees shall be spaced within the required buffer zones in accordance with Table 15.720.030-2, with trees to be spaced on center. Table 15.720.030-2 – Spacing of Trees STANDAR D RESIDENTIA L (MULTI- COMMERCIA L RESIDENTIA L (SINGLE Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 31 of 57 FAMILY ) FAMILY ) Minimum Trees (24” box minim um) 1 per 20 linear feet 1 per 30 linear feet3 1 per 20 linear feet1 1 per 30 linear feet2,3 1 per 30 linear feet Notes: 1. Where adjacent to any residential use. 2. Where adjacent to any commercial . 3. Where adjacent to any right-of-way. 4. Tree boxes are containment systems that include trees as vegetation. They are similar to small bioretention cells and are designed to filter or infiltrate stormwater runoff. Tree boxes typically consist of an engineered soil mix, underdrain, and overflow, and are connected to the storm sewer system or other stormwater treatment system. 2. Shrub Requirements. Shrubs are required in all buffer areas, with a minimum of four shrubs, sized at 5-gallon, required for every tree. 3. Mulch Requirements. Ground covers shall be installed in all landscaped areas in accordance with mulch above. B. Utility Boxes & Installations. Clearances shall be approved pursuant to the applicable utility provider. 15.720.040 050 Parking Lot Landscaping. Parking lot landscaping is separate and distinct from landscaping buffers. A. Parking Lot EdgesBuffers. 1. Parking lot landscaping requirements may be met in whole or in part with required landscaping buffers. 2. Landscape buffers may be crossed by drive aisles connecting to abutting land. 32. No parking is allowed within a required landscape buffer. B. Parking Lot Interior. At least ten 10 percent (10%) of the parking stall area of lots containing less than fifty (50) parking or fewer spaces, and at least 15 fifteen percent (15%) of the parking stall area of lots containing fifty (50) or more parking spaces, shall be landscaped. C. Tree Requirements. 1. One (1) tree is required per ten (10) parking spaces. 2. A minimum of four (4) shrubs, sized at least 5 gallons, are required for every tree. Shrub equivalents shall match the buffer requirements. 3. No parking space may be more than one hundred (100) feet in any direction from a tree trunk. D. Location and Dimension of Landscaped Areas. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 32 of 57 1. The minimum size of tree planters within off-street parking areas shall be sixty (60) square feet per tree. 2. Planter islands shall be a minimum of ten (10’) feet in width and shall be protected with curb or wheel stops. E. Irrigation. Irrigation used in parking lot landscaped areas shall meet the technical requirements of MLUDC 15.720.020(F). F. Mulch. Mulch used in parking lot landscaped areas shall meet the requirements herein for mulch GE. Parking Lot Illumination. Parking lot illumination shall be considered in placement of trees, such that the illumination will not be obstructed by the tree, nor will the growth of tree be obstructed by the illumination structure. 15.720.060 Water Conservation. Landscape areas shall be irrigated in accordance with the Water Use Standards outlined in MLMC 13.07.060. 15.720.070 Approval of Landscape Plan and Installation of Landscaping. A. Landscape Plan Approval. After receipt of a complete landscape plan, all development applications shall be reviewed by the Department for compliance with this Chapter concurrently with and as a part of the review process of the principal use or structure and prior to issuance of any permit or approval except subdivisions. B. Residential Subdivisions. For residential major and short subdivisions, required landscaping shall be installed at the time each lot is developed, and no Certificate of Occupancy for the building shall be issued until the landscaping for that lot is installed or bonded for, as specified in herein. C. Installation or Security. No Certificate of Occupancy, or final inspection approval if no Certificate of Occupancy is required, shall be issued until one of the following occur: 1. The required landscaping is installed. 2. A bond or some other form of cash surety acceptable to the City is submitted at a value of one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the estimated cost to complete the landscaping according to the approved landscape plan. Upon completion of the landscape installation, the City shall promptly release the surety. If the required landscaping improvements are not made within six (6) months of occupancy of the building, the City may use the surety to install the landscaping. D. Alternative Landscape Design. The Director may approve modifications to the standards and designs set out in the Chapter if it provides equivalent means of achieving the intent of this Chapter or is consistent with the surrounding landscaping and meets the following: 1. The use of native and other drought tolerant plants and trees to retain the unique character of Moses Lake’s landscape; 2. Conserving water resources by using sustainable design and maintenance techniques and native and/or adapted plant species that are low water-use and regionally appropriate; Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 33 of 57 3. Incorporation of landscaping into storm water retention and infiltration; 4. Design includes heat and glare reduction; 5. Improving the appearance of development to protect and enhance public and private investments and property values; 6. Establishing an attractive streetscape that contributes to the character and appearance of the City; and 7. Providing screening to minimize the visual impacts of some types of facilities, structures, and equipment. 15.720.080 Prohibited Plants. A. The following trees are prohibited within public right-of-way, including planter strips: poplar, willow, cottonwood, fruit trees other than ornamental, nut trees, Siberian or Chinese elm, or any other tree species that may be declared a nuisance by the City for reasons of disease, exotic characteristics, or impairing or destroying property necessary to the health, welfare, and safety of the citizens of the City. B. The following trees are prohibited within one hundred (100) feet of a public sewer: poplar, willow, elm, cottonwood, or any other tree species with invasive roots. C. Any plant listed by the Grant County Weed District No. 2 as a noxious weed is prohibited. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 34 of 57 Chapter 15.725 FENCES, SCREENING, AND REFUSE STORAGE STANDARDS Sections: 15.725.010 Fencing. 15.725.020 Refuse Storage. 15.725.010 Fencing. A fence permit issued by the Department is required for all fence construction regardless of zoning designation. Fence permits are processed under the Type I review. A. Residential Zoning Districts. The following regulations shall apply to all residential zoning districts: a. Front yard fence height: four feet (4’) or less for solid fences and five feet (5’) or less for non-sight obscuring fences. b. Side or rear yard fence height: up to six feet (6’) in height. c. The fence shall be constructed behind the sidewalk, if installed, and shall be setback from the sidewalk or street, if no sidewalk has been installed, at least eighteen (18) inches. cd. Lots with double street frontage may have a fence up to six feet (6’) in height on the property along right of way for the side not used as a point of access, outside of the clear view triangle, and setback to the front setback. The adjacent strip of land between the fence and the back of the adjacent sidewalk shall be improved by the property owner concurrent with the fence installation. The property owner shall provide a ground cover plan for the strip of land as part of the fence permit application process. The strip of land shall be maintained clear of rubbish and debris. de. Fences may be constructed of wood, masonry, chain-link, vinyl, or similar materials employed by standard building practice. Fences shall not be made of tires or similar salvage materials not originally designed as structural components of fences or buildings. ef. All fencing materials must be located inside the property line, and a landscaping treatment is required for the exterior side of the fence up to the hard surface pathway. This area shall be maintained by the property owner. The property owner shall provide a ground cover plan for the strip of land as part of the fence permit application process. The strip of land shall be maintained clear of rubbish and debris. The landscaping treatment plan is required in conjunction with the fence permit application and shall include a minimum treatment of grass, decorative rock, wood, bark, or any combination of such materials, or similar materials, in a manner that will minimize disturbance by natural elements or pedestrians. fg. The provisions of this section shall not apply to fences, walls, or shrubbery owned or maintained by the City, or to fences constructed or maintained by any other governmental body or agency, for which the principal purpose is inherent to public safety. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 35 of 57 B. Nonresidential Zoning Districts. The following regulations shall apply to all zoning districts and overlays, excluding residential districts: ia. Fences shall not exceed eight feet in height without a variance. bii. The height of the fence shall be measured from the base of the fence. c. The fence shall be constructed behind the sidewalk, if installed, and shall be setback from the sidewalk or street, if no sidewalk has been installed, at least eighteen (18) inches. iiid. Barbed wire may be used for security purposes only on the upper one-quarter of the fence unless the use is adjacent to a residential zoning district, in which case no barbed wire shall be allowed on the portion of the fence adjacent to the residential zoning district. An administrative exception may be granted by the Director for public utility distribution or transmission facilities seeking relief from barbed wire requirements. C. Clearview Triangle. All corner lots shall maintain a vehicular sight triangle for safety purposes. A sight triangle shall be formed by measuring from the intersection of the extended curb line or the traveled right-of-way (if no curbs exist) of the adjacent street to a distance of fifty feet (50’) from the corner point. The third side of the triangle is the Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 36 of 57 straight line connecting the two (2) fifty foot (50’) sides. Within the area comprising the triangle, no fence, shrub, or other physical obstruction higher than thirty-six inches (36”) above the established street grade shall be permitted. D. Electric Fences. Electric fences shall be prohibited in all zones. E. Fence Maintenance. It shall be the responsibility of the owner and/or occupant of the property where a fence is erected to maintain the structure in good repair at all times. When a portion of the fence exceeding twenty-five percent (25%) of the street frontage is found to be in a deteriorated condition or in need of repair, including, but not limited to, broken or missing structural components, or the fence is substantially less than perpendicular to grade, the Building Official may order the fencing to be repaired, replaced, or removed depending on the condition of the fence. Such order shall be in writing. If the fencing is ordered to be replaced, then new fencing shall meet the current regulations. F. Right-of-Way. The fence shall be constructed to avoid placement over public utilities and municipal improvements. The City and the public utility companies may remove a fence located within a City right-of-way for installation, repair, or replacement of municipal improvements and public utilities without being required to reconstruct the fence, wall, or hedge. However, the owner may have the fence reconstructed as part of the project; provided, that the owner pays for all reconstruction costs. 15.725.020 Refuse Storage. The following regulations shall apply to all zoning districts and overlays, excluding single-family dwellings and single duplex projects. All outdoor trash, garbage, and Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 37 of 57 refuse storage areas shall meet standards for dimensions and access provided by the City- contracted solid waste collection service, in addition to the following: A. Shall be located inside a dumpster. B. Shall not be located in any required street setback area. C. Shall be located behind buildings when feasible. D. Shall be placed inside a one hundred percent (100%) sight-obscuring containment area (excluding alleys), when visible from abutting properties, consisting of slatted fencing and/or landscaping. E. Shall be placed inside a one hundred percent (100%) sight-obscuring containment area (excluding alleys), when visible from a public street, finished with materials similar to the exterior material of the primary structure. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 38 of 57 Chapter 15.730 NONCONFORMING USES AND STRUCTURES Sections: 15.730.010 Applicability. 15.730.020 Benign and Detrimental Nonconformities. 15.730.030 Nonconforming Use. 15.730.040 Nonconforming Structure. 15.730.050 Nonconforming Lots. 15.730.010 Applicability. Any use, structure, lot or other site improvement, which was legally established prior to the effective date of a land use regulation that rendered it nonconforming, shall be considered nonconforming if: A. The use is now prohibited or cannot meet use limitations applicable to the zone in which it is located; or B. The use, structure, or lot does not comply with the development standards or other requirements of the MLUDC. A change in the required permit review process shall not create a nonconformance. 15.730.020 Benign and Detrimental Nonconformities. The provisions of this Chapter distinguish benign nonconformities from detrimental nonconformities based on the differing levels of impacts that the various types of nonconformities may cause to surrounding uses that conform to the surrounding zoning, land uses, and basic health, safety and welfare. A. Benign Nonconformity. A nonconformity that does not have a negative impact on the health and safety of the public but may have an impact on public welfare. Examples may include not enough landscaping, too few parking spaces, or minimal deviation from dimensional standards. B. Detrimental Nonconformity. A nonconformity that has a negative impact on the health and safety of the public. Examples include uses involving hazardous materials, such as gasoline, in single-family neighborhoods, uses that produce significant noise, such as body shops or paint shops, uses that have been deemed incompatible, such as adult entertainment establishments near schools, or uses that have large trip generation characteristics such as drive-through restaurants. The Director shall make a written determination as to whether a nonconformity is benign or detrimental and include the rationale for such determination. Such determination shall be subject to Type I permit review processes for purposes of notice and appeal. 15.730.030 Nonconforming Use. A. Expansion of Nonconforming Uses. No existing building, structure, or land devoted to a nonconforming use shall be expanded, enlarged, extended, reconstructed, intensified, or structurally altered unless the use thereof is changed to a use permitted in the district in which such building, structure, or land is located except as follows: When authorized by conditional use permit, a benign nonconforming use may be expanded, Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 39 of 57 enlarged, extended, reconstructed, intensified, or structurally altered as long as the intensity of the benign nonconformity is the same or smaller. B. Change of Nonconforming Use. When authorized by the Director, a benign nonconforming use may be changed to a similar use that does not increase the intensity of impacts on surrounding conforming uses. For example, a change from a benign nonresidential use in a residential zone to another benign use shall be acceptable. C. Discontinuance of Nonconforming Use. When a detrimental nonconforming use of land or a nonconforming use of all or part of a structure is discontinued or abandoned for a period of twelve (12) months, such use shall not be resumed, notwithstanding any reserved intent not to abandon such use. Normal seasonal cessation of use, or temporary discontinuance for purposes of maintenance or improvements, shall not be included in determination of the twelve (12) month period of discontinuance. Evidence that such use has been actively available and marketed for sale or lease shall be considered by the director in determining if a nonconforming use has been discontinued. The Applicant may request an additional twelve (12) months after the expiration of the above text from the Director. D. Reversion to Nonconforming Use. If a nonconforming use is changed to a permitted use, the nonconforming use shall not be resumed. E. Residential Exception to Nonconforming Use Status. Legally established residential uses located in any zoning district shall not be deemed nonconforming in terms of use and density provisions and shall be a legal use. 15.730.040 Nonconforming Structure. No nonconforming structure may be expanded, enlarged, or extended where they increase an existing nonconformity. Nonconforming buildings may be repaired and maintained provided such work does not increase an existing nonconformity. Reconstruction of a nonconforming building or structure when damaged by fire or other natural disasters may be constructed within the same footprint and height of the structure prior to the damage. 15.730.050 Nonconforming Lots. A. Residential zones. In any residential zone, and in nonresidential zones where single- family dwellings are permitted, a single-family dwelling and customary accessory buildings may be erected or modified on any nonconforming lot of record, even though such lot fails to meet lot area and width requirements of the zone in which such lot is located; provided, that: 1. Such lot is a legal lot of record; and 2. Such lot is in separate ownership; and 3. The proposed development meets other applicable development standards such as setbacks and building height. B. Other Districts. In any other district, permitted building and structures may be constructed on a nonconforming parcel or legal lot of record, provided applicable Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 40 of 57 development standards such as setbacks, landscaping, and off-street parking requirements are met. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 41 of 57 Chapter 15.735 SIGNS Sections: 15.735.010 Purpose. 15.735.020 Development Permit Required. 15.735.030 Exemptions. 15.735.040 Prohibited Signs. 15.735.050 Sign Permit Applications. 15.735.060 General Provisions. 15.735.070 Calculation of Sign Face Area: 15.735.080 Sign Types Permitted By Zone. 15.735.090 Sign Illumination. 15.735.100 Projection Over the Right-of-Way. 15.735.110 Wall Signs. 15.735.120 Temporary Signs. 15.735.130 Carried Signs. 15.735.140 Directional Signs. 15.735.150 Digital Signs. 15.735.160 Multiple-Building Complexes and Multiple-Tenant Buildings. 15.735.170 Freeway Signs. 15.735.180 Portable Signs. 15.735.190 Nonconforming Signs. 15.735.200 Maintenance of Signs. 15.735.210 Removal of Signs. 15.735.010 Purpose. The purpose of this Chapter is to promote the public health, safety, and welfare through a comprehensive system of reasonable, effective, consistent, content-neutral, and nondiscriminatory sign standards and requirements. It has also been adopted to promote the following: A. Minimum standards in order to promote traffic safety; B. Recognition of free speech rights by regulating signs in a content-neutral manner; C. The free flow of traffic and to protect pedestrians and motorists from injury and property damage caused by, or attributable to, cluttered, distracting, or illegible signs; D. Provide consistent and compatible sign design standards; and E. Adopt understandable regulations which enable the fair and consistent enforcement of this Chapter. This Chapter is not intended to restrict speech on the basis of its content, viewpoint, or message. Any classification of signs herein which purports to permit speech by reason of the type of sign, identity of the sign user, or otherwise, should be interpreted to allow commercial or noncommercial speech on the sign. Nothing in this Chapter should be construed to favor commercial speech over noncommercial speech. 15.735.020 Development Permit Required. No sign governed by the provisions of this Chapter shall be erected, structurally altered, or relocated by any person, firm, entity, or corporation without a permit issued by the City unless an exemption applies under this Chapter. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 42 of 57 15.735.030 Exemptions. The following signs are exempt from the permitting requirements of this Chapter: A. Flags. Any flags, subject to the following standards: 1. The maximum flagpole height shall be the maximum structure height of the underlying zoning district 2. Flagpoles shall meet applicable setback standards for accessory structures. B. Building Identification Numbers. Building identification numbers as required pursuant to the Moses Lake Municipal Code or any other City or state regulation. C. Certain Informational Signs. Memorial signs or tablets, names of buildings, stained glass windows, and dates of erection when cut into the surface or the facade of the building or when projecting not more than two inches. D. Governmental Signs. Signs installed by the City, County, or a federal or State governmental agency for the protection of the public health, safety, and general welfare, including, but not limited to, the following: 1. Emergency and warning signs necessary for public safety or civil defense. 2. Traffic or wayfinding signs erected and maintained by an authorized public agency. 3. Signs required to be displayed by law. 4. Signs showing the location of public facilities including public and private hospitals and emergency medical services. 5. Any sign, posting, notice, or similar sign placed by or required by a governmental agency in carrying out its responsibility to protect the public health, safety, and general welfare. E. Utility Signs. Signs of public utility companies indicating danger or which serve as an aid to public safety or which show the location of underground facilities. F. Certain Identification Wall Signs. Flush-mounted wall signs, used to identify the name and address of the occupant for each dwelling provided the sign does not exceed two square feet in sign area. G. Non-Visible Signs. Signs not visible beyond the boundaries of the lot or parcel upon which they are located, or from any public right-of-way. Any freestanding signs may a building permit for structural review. H. Alterations to Sign Face or Copy. Changes to the face or copy of changeable copy signs, digital signs, electronic messaging signs, provided such changes do not change the material or appearance of the sign as originally permitted by the City. I. Repair and Maintenance. The normal repair and maintenance, (painting, repainting, cleaning) of conforming or legal nonconforming signs that does not involve structural alteration of the sign or supporting structure. J. Public Art and Design Features. Sculptures, fountains, mosaics, murals, public art and design features which do not otherwise constitute a sign. K. Certain Informational Warning Signs. “No trespassing,” “no dumping,” “no parking,” “private” signs identifying essential public needs (i.e., restrooms, entrance, exit, telephone, etc.) and other informational warning signs, which shall not exceed three square feet in surface area. L. Illuminated Wall Highlights. Illuminated wall highlights that do not contain words, logos, or corporate images. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 43 of 57 M. Interior Signs. Signs or displays located entirely inside of a building and located at least three (3) feet away from transparent doors and windows. N. Temporary Signs. Temporary signs on private property or public property meeting the requirements of MLUDC 15.735.120. O. Vehicle Signs. Any sign on a vehicle, unless such vehicle is parked or stationed near an activity for the primary purpose of attracting public attention to such activity or unless such vehicle or mobile unit is regularly parked in any prominently visible location for the primary purpose of attracting public attention to the sign. P. Temporary Window Signs. Any temporary sign taped or otherwise affixed to the inside of a window, in such a manner as to be easily removed; provided, that the total area of the sign in any one window does not exceed that as allowed in this Chapter for window signs and temporary signs. 15.735.040 Prohibited Signs. The following signs are prohibited: A. Signs on any vehicle or trailer parked on public or private property and visible from a public right-of-way for the purpose of circumventing the provisions of this Chapter. This provision shall not prohibit signs painted on or magnetically attached to any vehicle operating in the normal course of business. B. Signs purporting to be, imitating, or resembling an official traffic sign or signal by its color, design, location, or illumination which could cause confusion with any official sign, or which obstruct the visibility of any traffic, street sign, signal, or pedestrian by glare or method of illumination. C. Signs attached to utility, streetlight, and traffic-control poles or facilities, signs attached to fences owned by the City, or signs placed on trees. D. Billboards. E. Flashing signs. F. Swinging projecting signs. G. Signs in a dilapidated (i.e., having peeling paint, major cracks or holes, and/or loose or dangling materials) or hazardous condition. H. Abandoned signs. I. Signs on doors, windows or fire escapes that restrict free ingress or egress. J. Roof signs. K. Any other sign not meeting the provisions of this Chapter. 15.735.050 Sign Permit Applications. The application for the erection, alteration, or relocation of any sign subject to the requirements of this Chapter shall include: A. Two (2) copies of a scaled drawing of the site plan which shows the site boundary, sidewalk and curb, driveways, buildings, other relevant site development or site limitations, and the location of the proposed building or freestanding sign or signs. The location of freestanding signs should be shown as dimension lines from nearest lot or parcel boundaries. B. Two (2) copies of scaled plans and elevations of the sign work, including sign and sign structure dimensions, sign height, structural detail, description, drawing, or picture of the sign copy, footing details, method of sign attachment to sign structure, building, or architectural appendage, illumination, specifications, and calculations for wind loads. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 44 of 57 C. An inventory of each and every existing sign on the site, including a description of the sign copy, type of sign, and sign dimensions. D. The Director may waive the submission of plans, specifications, and calculations when the structural aspect is of minor importance. E. A completed application with an inventory of each and every sign that will be erected, altered, or relocated, and the type of sign. 15.735.060 General Provisions. All signs, including exempt and temporary signs, shall comply with the following provisions: A. Construction shall satisfy the requirements of the building code and permanent signs must be manufactured of durable materials that withstand the effects of water and wind, as well as meet the following requirements: 1. Paper-faced signs, including vinyl-coated paper and those applied with adhesives, are not allowed. Canvas or vinyl signs must be durable; and 2. Sign faces made of canvas, fabric, vinyl, or similar pliable materials that are attached to permanent sign structures must be mounted behind a perimeter frame or trim cap so that the edges of the sign face are not exposed, except that flags made of one hundred percent spun polyester are exempt from this requirement. B. Except for exempt, portable, and temporary signs, all signs shall be permanently attached to a building or the ground. C. Signs attached to a building shall not exceed the height of the building, except as provided in this Chapter. D. All signs shall comply with the setback requirements set forth in this Chapter, except when the side or rear yard is a street frontage, then the front setback shall apply. E. In addition to the sign illumination requirements of MLUDC 15.735.090, lighting directed on or internal to any sign shall be shaded, screened, or directed so that the light’s intensity or brightness shall not adversely affect neighboring property or motor vehicle safety. F. In addition to the sign illumination requirements of MLUDC 15.735.090, any exterior lighting must be shielded and directed away from adjoining streets or residential uses. G. All signs together with their supports, braces, and guys shall be maintained in a safe and secure manner. H. The ratio of the area of the sign support, framing structure, or other decorative features which contain no written or advertising copy to the sign cabinet shall not be greater than 1:1. I. No signs shall be placed in the clear view triangle of roadways, driveways, or curb cuts as established in the MLUDC 15.725.010(C). J. The construction of temporary signs is limited to the materials described in the definition of “temporary sign” herein. In addition, a temporary sign must also conform to the requirements of this Chapter, including, but not limited to, MLUDC 15.735.120. K. No signs shall be affixed, connected, taped, zip-tied, tied, or otherwise attached to any City property, including, but not limited to, utility poles, utility boxes, fences, or street signs. Such signs will be removed by the City. L. No sign may be placed within the roadway portion of the City right-of-way except as otherwise permitted with a City right-of-way use or special event permit. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 45 of 57 M. No sign shall be erected or maintained if it is visible from the main traveled way of the interstate or primary system except as permitted by Chapter 47.42 RCW, entitled Highway Advertising Control Act – Scenic Vistas Act, and the regulations set forth in Chapter 468-66 WAC. 15.735.070 Calculation of Sign Face Area. The area of a sign face is the smallest circle, square, or rectangle that encloses a sign face or the largest plane of a three (3) dimensional sign. The area of a double-face sign face is the area of a single face. The area of a multiple-face sign face (other than a double-face sign face) is the sum of the areas of all sign faces. Only the sign portion of a structure, material, space, or device is calculated for the purpose of sign area face, except that the area of a cabinet sign or sign in a frame or border shall be based on the outside dimensions of the cabinet, frame, or border. The area of multiple signs on a structure, material, space, or device is the sum of the areas of all sign faces. The area of a sign face with multiple messages is the smallest circle, square, or rectangle that encloses all of the messages. 15.735.080 Sign Types Permitted By Zone. Table 15.825.080-1 – Type of Signs, Maximum Height, and Maximum Sign Area Permitted in Non- Residential Zones Zone Types of Signs Allowed Number of Signs Max. Sign Face Area Max. Sign Height Commercial or Mixed Use Wall No limit within maximum sign face area The total area shall not exceed 15% of the overall area of each façade. Top of Wall Permanent Freestanding 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Projecting 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Freeway No limit within maximum sign face area 350 square feet per site 45 feet Off-Premises Directional 1 per business 150 square feet 25 feet Off-Premises 1 sign 150 square feet 25 feet On-Premises Directional No limit 8 square feet 6 feet Industrial Wall No limit within maximum sign face area The total area shall not exceed 25% of the overall area of each façade. Top of Wall Permanent Freestanding 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Projecting 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Freeway No limit within maximum sign face area (Shall comply with Scenic Vista) 350 square feet per site 45 feet Off-Premises Directional 1 per business 150 square feet 25 feet Off-Premises 1 sign 150 square feet 25 feet On-Premises Directional No limit 8 square feet 6 feet Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 46 of 57 Public/Parks and Open Space Wall No limit within maximum sign face area The total area shall not exceed 25% of the overall area of each façade. Top of Wall Permanent Freestanding 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Projecting 1 per street frontage 150 square feet 25 feet Freeway No limit within maximum sign face area 350 square feet per site 45 feet Off-Premises Directional 1 per business 150 square feet 25 feet Off-Premises 1 sign 150 square feet 25 feet On-Premises Directional No limit 8 square feet 6 feet Notes: Temporary Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.120. Carried Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.130. Digital Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.150. Portable Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.180. Table 15.825.080-2 – Type of Signs, Maximum Height, and Maximum Sign Area Permitted in Residential Zones Development or Use Type Types of Signs Allowed Number of Signs Max. Sign Face Area Max. Sign Height Single-Family Subdivision Permanent Freestanding 1 per entrance 25 square feet 5 feet Multifamily Complex Permanent Freestanding 1 per entrance 25 square feet 8 feet On-Premises Directional No limit 8 square feet 6 feet Home Occupation Non-Illuminated Wall 1 per building 2 square feet Top of Wall Other Permitted Non- Residential Use Permanent Freestanding 1 per site 25 square feet 8 feet Non-Illuminated Wall 1 per building 6 square feet Top of Wall Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 47 of 57 On-Premises Directional No limit 8 square feet 6 feet Notes: Temporary Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.120. Carried Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.130. Digital Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.150. Portable Signs are regulated by MLUDC 15.735.180. 15.735.090 Sign Illumination. A. General Illumination Standards. 1. For purposes of illumination, all lights attached to a sign in any manner shall not extend more than five feet from the sign structure. 2. Internal or external sign lighting shall be shaded, hooded, site screened, or directed so that the light’s intensity or brightness shall neither adversely affect adjacent or nearby property, nor create a public nuisance, nor create a traffic hazard. 3. All internally lit signs shall integrate automatic dimming capability that adjusts to the brightness of ambient light at all times of the day and night subject to the following brightness limits: a. Daytime: 8,000 maximum nits. b. Nighttime: 1,000 maximum nits. This applies between 30 minutes after sunset and 30 minutes before sunrise. B. Hours of Illumination. Any illuminated sign located on a lot adjacent to or across the street from any residential zone and that may be visible within 200 feet of any residential zone shall not be illuminated between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. 15.735.100 Projection Over the Right-of-Way. A projecting sign is allowed over a sidewalk in right-of- way in the Commercial and Mixed Use zones where the building is not set back from right- of-way; provided, that the sign does not project more than eighty percent (80%) of the distance between the right-of-way line and back of curb line, and there is a minimum of eight feet (8’) vertical clearance under the sign. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 48 of 57 15.735.110 Wall Signs. All wall signs shall conform to the following provisions: A. Wall signs may be painted upon, attached flat to, or pinned away from the wall, but shall not project more than twelve inches from the wall. B. The number of wall signs is not regulated; provided, that the total area of the wall sign(s) may not exceed the area of the wall to which attached. C. Wall signs shall not extend above the height of the wall to which the wall sign is attached. 15.735.120 Temporary Signs. All temporary signs shall conform to the following: A. Prohibited Locations. 1. No temporary sign shall be placed in a required parking space, driveway, or clear view triangle. See MLUDC 15.725.010(C). 2. No temporary sign may be placed on City-owned property (not including a City right- of-way) unless in conjunction with an approved special event permit, temporary use permit, or other permission from the City. 3. No temporary sign shall be placed in the roadway. B. City Right-of-Way Locations. Temporary signs on the City right-of-way placed outside the roadway shall comply with the following requirements: 1. Allowed only between the property line and the back of the nearest curb, or where no curb exists, between the property line and the nearest edge of the pavement. Signs may not be placed on sidewalks, driveways, or other paved areas designed for pedestrians or vehicular use. 2. Approval of the abutting landowner is required. 3. Signs on stakes that can be manually pushed or hammered into the ground are allowed. All other signs are prohibited, unless specifically allowed by a right-of-way use permit. 4. Signs are limited to four square feet total and three feet in height, from the ground to the top of the sign. 5. Any temporary sign in the right-of-way that is dilapidated or a nuisance shall be removed by the person responsible for placement of the sign. 6. The City may allow other signs in a City right-of-way with a right-of-way use permit. C. Residential Zones. Temporary signs may be placed on property residentially zoned in accordance with the requirements of this section and the following: 1. One temporary window sign per residential unit not to exceed four square feet is allowed. 2. Freestanding signs, including post-mounted, stake and portable signs are allowed as follows: a. In low density residential zones temporary free-standing signs shall not exceed four square feet in size and five feet in height, if the sign is post-mounted on the ground, and not to exceed three feet in height if the sign is stake-mounted or portable. b. In medium and high density residential zones temporary free-standing signs shall not exceed six square feet in size and five feet in height if the sign is post- Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 49 of 57 mounted on the ground, and not to exceed three feet in height if the sign is stake-mounted or portable. F. Nonresidential Zones. Temporary signs are allowed in nonresidential zones in accordance with the requirements of this section and the following: 1. Window signs are limited to fifty percent of the window area. 2. Freestanding signs, including post-mounted, stake and portable signs are limited to four square feet and five feet in height if the temporary sign is mounted in the ground, and not to exceed three feet in height if the temporary sign is stake- mounted or portable. 3. Surface-mounted signs are limited to thirty square feet and must be flatly affixed to walls or to on-site fences either facing the abutting street or facing inward to the subject site. 15.735.130 Carried Signs. All carried signs shall conform to the following: A. Area. A carried sign shall not exceed eight square feet in area, and shall not exceed eight feet in height when held in place. B. Zone. Carried signs are permitted only in nonresidential zones. C. Design. A carried sign shall not be illuminated. Carried signs and persons carrying signs shall be limited to the hours from dawn until dusk. A carried sign cannot include any element of a prohibited sign, as described in MLUDC 15.735.040. D. Locations Allowed. Carried signs must stay at least fifteen feet away from an unsignalized street or driveway intersection, measured from the edge of the curb abutting the roadway or edge of the pavement if no curb exists. Carried signs must remain on the sidewalks adjacent to signalized intersections. In no event may a carried sign, or the person carrying the sign, impede or interfere with pedestrian or vehicular traffic. E. Locations Not Allowed. Carried signs shall not be located in any of the following places: 1. On any public property or within public rights-of-way, other than public sidewalks. 2. In parking aisles or stalls. 3. In driving lanes. 4. On fences, walls, boulders, planters, other signs, vehicles, utility facilities or other structures. 5. In a location or manner that results in a person with a carried sign physically interfering with motorists, pedestrians, or bicyclists. 15.735.140 Directional Signs. A. On-Premises Directional Signs. On-premises directional signs readable from the public right-of-way may be permitted in accordance with Tables 15.735.080-1 and 15.735.080- 2. On-premises directional signs may contain both directions and the business name or logo, provided the business name or logo shall not exceed fifty percent of the sign area. All on-premises directional signs shall meet the general provisions of this section, and shall not exceed ten square feet per sign face. B. Off-Premises Directional Signs. Off-premises directional signs readable from the public right-of-way may be permitted in accordance with Table 15.735.080-1, provided, that: Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 50 of 57 1. Each use located in a zone where off-premises directional signs are allowed is permitted one off-premises directional sign. 2. The off-premises sign contains only directional information and does not exceed thirty-two square feet in area nor twenty-five feet in height. 3. The off-premises signs are permanently installed on private property. 4. Only one off-premises sign is permitted on a parcel. 15.735.150 Digital Signs. A. Maximum Size. The maximum size of a digital sign is fifty percent of the total area of the sign permitted by Table 15.735.080-1, and no greater than fifty square feet. B. Density. There may be one digital sign per one hundred feet of street frontage. C. Zoning. Digital signs are allowed only in nonresidential zones. D. Motion. Digital signs may have no motions other than the change of the message. F. Hold Duration. The minimum hold between messages is eight seconds. G. Illumination. All digital signs must meet the illumination standards set forth in MLUDC 15.735.090. 15.735.160 Multiple-Building Complexes and Multiple-Tenant Buildings. A. Application. The following provisions shall apply to multiple-building complexes and multiple-tenant buildings in the Commercial and Mixed Use Zones. Tenants in such buildings or complexes may also have their own signs in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter. B. Number of Freestanding Signs. Each multiple-building complex shall be allowed one freestanding sign on each street frontage in accordance with Table 15.735.080-1. When the street frontage is longer than four hundred feet: 1. One additional freestanding sign shall be permitted for each additional four hundred feet of street frontage or part thereof; or 2. A single, larger freestanding sign can be erected in accordance with Table 15.735.080-1. If option 1, as set forth in subsection (B)(1) of this section, is selected, no freestanding sign shall be placed closer than two hundred (200) feet to any other freestanding sign or exceed the standards in Table 15.735.080-1. These provisions shall also apply to each multiple-tenant building, unless it is a part of a multiple-building complex. The allowable freestanding sign(s) may be used to advertise one or more of the uses in the multiple- building complex or multiple-tenant building. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 51 of 57 15.735.170 Freeway Signs. A. Location. A freeway sign may be used to substitute an allowable freestanding sign where there is more than one street frontage, when the use is within two hundred fifty feet of the freeway right-of-way. B. Number of Freeway Signs. Only one freeway sign is permitted on each parcel, multiple- building complex or for each development, whichever is more restrictive. C. Uses with Only One Frontage. Uses within the area described in subsection B of this section with only one street frontage may install a freeway sign in addition to the permitted freestanding sign. D. Sign Height. The maximum height for freeway signs is shown in Table 15.735.080-1. 15.735.180 Portable Signs. Portable signs, including sandwich board, trailered and portable pole- mounted signs, shall comply with the following standards: A. Zone. Portable signs are allowed only in nonresidential zones. B. Design and Materials. Portable signs must be designed with durable materials, otherwise they will be regulated as temporary signs under MLUDC 15.735.120. Portable signs must be designed to withstand wind and include a heavy weighted base for pole- mounted signs, and a heavy weight suspended between the opposing faces of a sandwich board sign. Portable signs cannot be illuminated. C. Size and Height. Portable signs shall be a maximum of four feet in height and maximum of three feet in width. When measuring the height, measurement shall be from the ground to the top of the sign, and shall include any support structure, such as a trailer. When measuring the width, measurement shall include the full width of the sign and any support structures. D. Number. Not more than two portable signs may be displayed per business, per tenant space. The total square feet of the portable signs per business or tenant space shall not exceed twenty-four feet in the event two signs are displayed. E. Location. Portable signs must be located no further than ten feet from the primary building of the business, or located not farther than ten feet from the site’s driveway entrance. No portable sign may be located on the City right-of-way, which includes the sidewalk, without a right-of-way use permit or other permit allowing such use issued by the City. No portable sign may be located in a clear view triangle or obstruct pedestrian or vehicular traffic. See MLUDC 15.725.010(C). Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 52 of 57 F. Display Hours. Portable signs may be displayed during business or operating hours only. 15.735.190 Nonconforming Signs. Signs lawfully existing under all codes and ordinances in effect at the time this Chapter is enacted or amended may continue to be maintained and operated as a legal nonconforming sign so long as it remains otherwise lawful; provided, that: A. No sign shall be changed in any manner that increases its noncompliance with the provisions of the MLUDC. B. If the sign is structurally altered or moved, its legal nonconforming status shall be voided, and the sign will be required to conform to the provisions of this Chapter. Nothing in this section shall be construed to restrict normal structural repair and maintenance. C. The sign is not a hazardous or abandoned sign. D. The sign is not a portable sign, temporary sign, or an illegal sign. 15.735.200 Maintenance of Signs. It is unlawful for any owner of record, lessor, lessee, manager, or other person having lawful possession or control over a building, structure, or parcel of land to fail to maintain any signs on the building, structure, or parcel in compliance with this Chapter and the MLUDC. Signs placed on public property pursuant to this Chapter shall be maintained by the sign owner. Failure to maintain a sign constitutes a violation of this Chapter and shall be subject to enforcement. 15.735.210 Removal of Signs. Any vacant or unused sign, support structures, poles, or other remnants of old signs which are currently not in use, or are not proposed for immediate reuse, shall be removed. In addition to the remedies of the MLUDC, the Director shall have the authority to require the repair, maintenance, or removal of any signor sign structure which has become dilapidated or represents a hazard to the safety, health, or welfare of the public, at the cost of the sign or property owner in accordance with Chapter 1.20 MLMC. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 53 of 57 Chapter 15.740 OUTDOOR LIGHTING Sections: 15.740.010 Applicability. 15.740.020 Exemptions. 15.740.030 Lighting Standards and Guidelines. 15.740.040 Submission of Plans. 15.740.050 Alternative Materials or Methods of Construction or Installation/Operation. 15.740.010 Applicability. A. All outdoor lighting fixtures that are to be installed on private and public property in association with any building permit application or subdivision application shall comply with this Chapter. This Chapter does not apply to interior lighting. Types of outdoor lighting to which this Chapter applies include, but are not limited to, lighting for: 1. Building and structures including, but not limited to, overhangs and canopies. 2. Recreational areas. 3. Parking lot lighting. 4. Landscape and architectural lighting. B. The City’s Building Official shall administer and enforce this Chapter. 15.740.020 Exemptions. The following are exempt from the provisions of this Chapter: A. Traffic control signals and devices. B. Public street lights; provided, however, public street lights must conform to the most current version of the City’s Public Works Standards. C. Temporary emergency lighting (i.e. fire, police, medical personnel, repair workers) or warning lights. D. Moving vehicle lights. E. Navigation lights (e.g. on radio/television towers, microwave towers) or any other lights where state or federal statute or other provision of the MLUDC requires lighting that cannot comply with this Chapter. In such situations, lighting shall be shielded to the maximum extent possible, and lumens shall be minimized to the maximum extent possible, while still complying with state or federal statute. F. Seasonal decorations. G. Outdoor lighting approved by the building official for temporary or periodic events (e.g. fairs, nighttime construction). H. Outdoor lighting fixtures installed prior to the effective date of the ordinance codified in this Chapter. I. Fossil fuel lights. 15.740.030 Lighting standards and guidelines. The following general standards shall apply to all nonexempt outdoor lighting fixtures and accent lighting unless specifically noted: A. Shielding. Outdoor lighting fixtures and accent lighting with 2,000 lumens or more must be shielded and aimed downward. The shield must mask the direct horizontal surface of the light source. The light must be aimed to ensure that the illumination is only pointing Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 54 of 57 downward onto the ground surface, with no escaping direct light permitted to contribute to light pollution by shining upward into the sky. B. Limitation on Light Trespass. All outdoor lighting fixtures and accent lighting shall be designed, installed, located and maintained in such a manner that limits light trespass. C. Accent Lighting. Accent lighting shall be directed downward onto the illuminated object or area and not toward the sky or onto adjacent properties. Direct light emissions of such accent lighting shall not be visible above the roof line or beyond the building, structure, or object edge. D. Special Object Lighting. Bridge, flag, fountain, statue, monument, similar public artwork, feature lighting and private street lighting are permitted provided such lighting does not cause the spilling of direct light to other properties or traveled public ways. E. Sports Field Lighting. Lighting shall be fully shielded with an allowance of five percent uplighting. Sports field lighting shall be exempt from the light trespass provisions of this Chapter; provided, however, such light shall be extinguished when not in use and fixtures shall be aimed to control light trespass to the extent possible for the mounting height and required shielding. F. Lighting within the Industrial Districts. Fixtures shall be aimed to control light trespass to the extent possible for the mounting height and required shielding. Mounted lighting height shall not exceed 50 feet. G. New Nonresidential and Multifamily Lighting Standards. An exterior lighting plan providing appropriate lighting levels in all areas used by pedestrians or automobiles, including building entries, walkways, parking areas, circulation areas, and other open space areas shall be submitted and meet the following standards and guidelines: 1. All public areas shall be lighted with average minimum and maximum levels as follows: a. Minimum (for low or non-pedestrian and vehicular traffic areas) of one-half (0.5) foot-candles; b. Moderate (for moderate or high volume pedestrian areas) of one to two (2) foot-candles; and c. Maximum (for high volume pedestrian areas and building entries) of four (4) foot-candles; 2. Lighting shall be provided at consistent levels, with gradual transitions between maximum and minimum levels of lighting and between lit areas and unlit areas. Highly contrasting pools of light and dark areas shall be avoided; 3. Parking lot lighting fixtures shall be non-glare and mounted no more than twenty- five (25) feet above the ground, with lower fixtures preferable so as to maintain a human scale; 4. Pedestrian-scaled lighting (light fixtures no taller than fifteen (15) feet) is required in areas with high anticipated pedestrian activity ; and 5. Vegetation and landscaping shall be maintained in a manner that does not obstruct security lighting. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 55 of 57 Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 56 of 57 Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24 Part 15.700 Community and Project Design Standards Page 57 of 57 15.740.040 Submission of Plans. A. Submission Contents. The Applicant for any building permit or subdivision approval involving outdoor lighting fixtures shall submit with the application evidence that the proposed work will comply with this Chapter. The submission shall contain but shall not necessarily be limited to the following: 1. Plans indicating the location on the premises of all proposed newly installed or relocated outdoor lighting fixtures; 2. Description of all proposed newly installed or relocated outdoor lighting fixtures. The description may include, but is not limited to, catalog cuts and illustrations by manufacturers (including sections where required), lamp types, wattages, and initial lumen outputs; and 3. Photometric data, such as that furnished by manufacturers, or similar showing the angle of cut-off of proposed newly installed or relocated outdoor light emissions. B. Additional Submission. The above required plans, descriptions, and data shall be sufficiently complete to enable the Building Official to readily determine whether compliance with the requirements of this Chapter will be secured. If such plans, descriptions, and data cannot enable this ready determination, the Applicant shall additionally submit such certified reports of tests as will do so; provided, that these tests shall have been performed and certified by a recognized testing laboratory. C. Subdivisions. If any subdivision proposes to have installed street or other common or public area outdoor lighting, submission of the information as described in subsection (A) of this section shall be required for all such lighting, and the lighting shall comply with the most current version of the City’s Public Works Standards. D. Lamp or Fixture Substitution. A change request must be submitted to the Building Official for approval prior to substitution of any approved outdoor light fixture or type of light source. 15.740.050 Alternative Materials or Methods of Construction or Installation/Operation. The provisions of this Chapter are not intended to prevent the use of any design, material, or method of installation or operation not specifically prescribed by this Chapter, provided any such alternate has been approved by the Building Official to meet the purpose and intent of this Chapter. Council-Planning UDC Workshop 8-8-24