Loading...
07082014 Part 3June 30, 2014 TO: City Manager for Council Consideration FROM: Community Development Director SUBJECT: Resolution -Nuisance Abatement -1170 Grand -Sanchez Attached is a resolution providing for the abatement of nuisances at 1170 Grand, owned by Pedro and Maria Sanchez. The Council should hold a hearing to consider the allegations of the Code Enforcement Officer that the property contains a public nuisance which has not been corrected. If the Council concurs that a public nuisance exists, the resolution should be adopted allowing the City to remove the public nuisance. The resolution is attached for Council consideration. Respec~itted Gilbert Alvarado Community Development Director GA:jt RESOLUTION NO. 3~ ~ 4 A RESOLUTION DETERMINING THAT PEDRO V. AND MARIA A SANCHEZ ARE THE OWNERS OF CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY WITHIN THE CITY; THAT A NUISANCE REQUIRING ABATEMENT BY CITY FORCES OR FORCES CONTRACTED BY THE CITY EXISTS ON SUCH PROPERTY; AND DIRECTING THE USE OF SUCH FORCES TO ABATE THE NUISANCE FOUND Recitals: 1. Real Property Location and Ownership. It is alleged by a Code Enforcement Officer of the City, a person authorized to enforce the ordinances and municipal code of the City, that the real property located at Lot 9, Block 2, Hayden Estates Second Addition, Parcel #111956000, Moses Lake, Washington, is the site of public nuisance violations of Moses Lake Municipal Code (MLMC) 8.14. The records of Grant County show the owners of the subject property to be Pedro V. and Maria A Sanchez, 812 S. 4th Avenue, Pasco, WA 99301-5708. 2. Notice. On May 22, 2014, the Code Enforcement Officer caused to be delivered by regular mail and certified mail to the owner of record of the subject property a Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity. No appeal was filed to challenge that order. The time to comply under that order has passed. The nuisance described in that order has not been abated by correction of the condition of the property and a nuisance continues to exist on the subject property. On June 24, 2014, the Code Enforcement Officer caused to be delivered to Pedro Sanchez a notice of the intent of the City Council to consider adoption of a resolution such as this at its meeting of July 8, 2014. Such notice was in writing, in the English language and was delivered by return receipt mail and regular mail to the record owner of the subject property. 3. Violations. It has been established by the Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity that the following violations exist on the subject property and have not been corrected: 3.1 A violation of MLMC 8.14.030 U -Except for any designated public park land, natural area, or environmentally sensitive area, or any undeveloped parcels of land not adjacent to developed areas or which are used for agricultural purposes, all grasses, weeds, or other vegetation growing or which has grown and died, which is determined to be a fire or safety hazard or a nuisance to persons, shall not exceed twelve inches (12") in height measured above the ground. 4. Hearing. On July 8, 2014 the Moses Lake City Council conducted a hearing to consider the allegations of the Code Enforcement Officer that the subject property contains a public nuisance ordered corrected which remains uncorrected and that the record owner is responsible for the costs of correcting and abating such violations if such corrections and abatement is accomplished by City forces or forces contracted by the City for such purpose. All interested persons were permitted to provide written or oral evidence relevant to the issue. 5. Evidence: 5.1. The following persons testified under oath: Rick Rodriguez, Moses Lake Code Enforcement Officer 5.2. The following exhibits were made a part of the record of the proceedings: EXHIBIT #1: Moses Lake Municipal Code Chapters 8.14.030.U EXHIBIT #2: "Notice To Correct Unsafe or Unlawful Condition" dated May 6, 2014 EXHIBIT #3: Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity dated May 22, 2014 from the Code Enforcement Officer addressed to Pedro Sanchez, 812 S. 4th Avenue, Pasco, WA 99301-5708. Resolved: EXHIBIT #4: Pictures taken by Code Enforcement Officer of the property located at Lot 9, Block 2, Hayden Estates Second Addition, Moses Lake, Washington. EXHIBIT #5: Letter dated June 24, 2014, from the Code Enforcement Officer to Pedro Sanchez advising the property owner of the hearing regarding abatement of property, scheduled for July 8, 2014. 1. A public nuisance in violation of MLMC 8.14 exists on the subject property at lot 9, Block 2, Hayden Estates, Second Addition,, Moses Lake, Washington. Pedro V. and Maria A. Sanchez, 812 S. 4th Avenue, Pasco, WA 99301-5708 are the record contract owners of the subject property per the records of Grant County. 2. The public nuisance located upon the subject property consists of: 2.1. Weeds and/or grass over 12" high 3. The maintenance of these public nuisance violations on the subject property by the record owner is detrimental to the health, safety, welfare, peace and tranquility of the residents of the City impacting the quality of life and diminishing property values. 4. Pedro V. and Maria A Sanchez, the record contract owners, have fifteen (15) days from the date of the adoption of this resolution to cause the nuisance violations listed herein to be removed to the satisfaction of the Code Enforcement Officer. Those improvements include the following: 4.1 Cut and remove weeds on the property 5. City staff shall provide a status report to City Council on the progress of the record contract owners and occupant to make the clean up required on the subject property. If the improvements, as listed above, are not to the satisfaction of the Code Enforcement Officer, the City is authorized to use City forces or contract forces to cause the identified public nuisances to be removed from the subject property to the satisfaction of the City Manager. All costs of any removal of the identified public nuisances done at City expense shall be recovered by the City Manager by all reasonable means including immediate assignment of the costs so incurred for collection. 6. A copy of this resolution shall be provided to the record contract owner by return receipt and regular mail after its approval by the City Council. Adopted by the City Council on July 8, 2014. Dick Deane, Mayor ATTEST: W. Robert Taylor, Finance Director 8.14.030 A B. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J. K. Nuisance Defined. Each of the following conditions, unless otherwise permitted by law, is declared to constitute a public nuisance, and whenever the Code Enforcement Officer deter- mines that any of these conditions exist upon any premises or in any stream, drainage way or wetlands, the officer may require or provide for the abatement thereof pursuant to this chapter. The existence of any trash, dirt, filth, and carcass of any animal, waste shrubs, accumulation of lawn or yard trimmings or other offensive matter. Defective or overflowing septic or sewage systems, and the existence of any noxious, foul, or putrid liquid or substance which poses a health hazard or creates a noxious odor. Any man-caused pool of standing or stagnant water, except storm drainage systems, which serves as a breeding area for insects. Accumulation of garbage, decaying vegetation, manure, dead animals, or other noxious things in a street or alley, or on public or private property to an extent injurious to the public health as determined by the Health Officer. All other acts, failure to act, occupations, or use of property which is determined by the Health Officer to be a menace to the health of the public. All limbs of trees which are less than seven (7) feet above the surface of any public sidewalk, or twelve (12) feet above the surface of any street. All buildings, other structures, or portions thereof which have been damaged by fire, decay, neglect, or have otherwise deteriorated or become dilapidated so as to endanger the safety of the public. All explosives, flammable liquids, and other dangerous substances stored or used in any manner in violation of the State Fire Code. The keeping or harboring of any dog, fowl, or other animal which by frequent or habitual howling, yelping, barking, crowing, or in the making of other noises, annoys or disturbs the public, or the habitual allowing of dogs kept at any one address to run at large in violation of Chapter 6.05 of the Moses Lake Municipal Code entitled "Animal Control". Making or causing to be made by any means whatsoever any noise of any kind which is a violation of Chapters 8.28 of the Moses Lake Municipal Code entitled "Noise Control". The frequent, repetitive, or continuous sound made by any secured, unsecured, or deteriorated membrane or sheet metal, being moved by the wind or other source, which unreasonably interferes with the peace, comfort and repose of adjacent property owners or possessors. L. Dumping, throwing, placing, leaving or causing or permitting to be dumped, thrown, placed or left, any filth, paper, cans, glass, rubbish, trash garbage, grass trimmings, shrub trimming, and shrubbery of any kind, in or upon any street, alley, sidewalk, ditch, or public or private property of another in the city. M. The erecting, maintaining, using, placing, depositing, leaving or permitting to be or remain in or upon any private lot, building , structure or premises, or in or upon any street, alley, sidewalk, park, parkway or other public or private place in the city, any one or more of the following disorderly, disturbing, unsanitary, fly-producing, rat-harboring, disease-causing places, conditions or things: 1. Any putrid, unhealthy or unwholesome bones, meat, hides, skins, or whole or any part of any dead animal, fish or fowl, or waste pa rts of fish, vegetable or animal Exhibit 1 Page 1 of 4 matter in any quantity; but nothing herein shall prevent the temporary retention of waste in approved covered receptacles. 2. Any privies, vaults, cesspools, sumps, pits or like places wh ich are not securely protected from flies and rats, or which are foul or malodorous. 3. Any fi lthy, littered or trash-covered dwellings, cellars, house yards, barnyards, stable yards, factory yards, vacant areas in the rear of stores, vacant lots, houses, buildings or premises. 4. Any animal manure in any quantity which is not securely protected from flies or weather conditions, or wh ich is kept or handled in violation of any ordinance of the city. 5. Any poison oak or poison ivy, Russian th istle or other noxious weeds, as defined by Chapter 8.22 of the Moses Lake Municipal Code entitled "Noxious Weed Control" whether growing or otherwise; but nothing herein shall prevent the temporary retention of such weeds in approved covered receptacles. 6. Any bottles, cans, glass, ashes, small pieces of scrap iron, wire, metal articles, bric- a-brac, broken crockery, broken glass, broken plaster and all such trash , or abandoned material, unless it is kept in approved covered bins or galvanized iron receptacles. 7. Any trash, litter, rags, accumulations or empty barrels, boxes, crates, packing cases, mattresses, bedding , excelsior, packing hay, straw or other packing material, lumber not neatly piled, scrap iron, tin or other metal not neatly piled, or anything whatsoever in which flies or rats may breed or multiply or which may be a fire hazard. N. The permitting to remain outside any dwelling, building, or other structure, or within any unoccupied or abandoned building, dwelling, or other structure, in a place accessible to children, any abandoned, unattended, or discarded ice chest, refrigerator or other airtight contained, which does not have the door, lid or other locking device removed. 0 . Any pit, hole, basin or excavation which is unguarded or dangerous to life or has been abandoned, or is no longer used for the purpose constructed, or is maintained contrary to statutes, ordinances. or regulations. P. Any well or storage tank permitted to remain on any public or private property without being securely closed or barring any entrance or trap door thereto, or without filling or capping any well. Q. The repair or abandonment of any automobile, truck, or other motor vehicle of any kind upon the public streets or alleys of the city. R. The keeping or permitting the existence of any bees or other insects, reptiles, rodents , fowl, or any other animals, domestic or wild, in any manner contrary to law, or which affect the safety of the public. S. The existence of any fence, other structure, or th ing on private or public property abutting or fronting upon any public street, sidewalk, or place, which is sagging, leaning, fallen, decayed or is otherwise dilapidated and creating an unsafe condition. T. The existence of any vine, shrub, or plant growing on, around, or in front of any fire hydrant, utility pole, utility box, or any other appliance or facility provided for fire protection, public or private utility purposes in such a way as to obscure from view or impair access thereto. Exhibit 1 Page 2 of 4 U. Except for any designated public park land, natural area, or environmentally sensitive area , or any undeveloped parcels of land not adjacent to developed areas or which are used for agricultural purposes, all grasses, weeds, or other vegetation growing or which has grown and died, which is determined to be a fire or safety hazard or a nuisance to persons, shall not exceed twelve inches (12") in height measured above the ground. 1. The above exception may be waived and additional maintenance required by the Code Enforcement Officer if he determines such action is necessary to protect the safety of persons or adjoining property. 2. All maintenance shall be done in a manner so that soil stability will not be disrupted or disturbed. Grass, weed, or vegetation control shall not include plowing, discing, or scraping the soil to eliminate the grasses, weeds, or other vegetation unless a soil stabilization plan , which will minimize blowing dust and maintain soil stability and which shall be approved by the city prior to any plowing, discing, or scraping, is implemented immediately. V. The existence of any dead, diseased, infected, or dying tree, shrub, or other vegetation which may pose a danger to vegetation, crops, property, or persons. W. The existence of any accumulation of materials or objects in a location when the same endangers property, safety or constitutes a fire hazard. X. The depositing or burning or causing to be deposited or burned in any street, alley, sidewalk, parkway or other public place which is open to travel, of any hay, straw, paper, wood, boards, boxes, leaves, manure or other rubbish or material. Y. The storage or keeping on any premises for more than thirty days of any used or unused building materials as defined in Section 8.14.010 (F), whose retail cost new would exceed one hundred dollars, without a special permit from the building official; provided, that nothing herein shall: 1. Prohibit such storage without a permit when done in conjunction with a construction project for which a building permit has been issued and which is being prosecuted diligently to completion. 2. Prohibit such storage without a permit upon the premises of a bona fide lumber yard, dealer in building materials or other commercial enterprise when the same is permitted under the zoning ordinance and other applicable laws. 3. Make lawful any such storage or keeping when it is prohibited by other ordinances or laws. Z. The existence on any premises of any unused and abandoned trailer, house trailer, automo- bile, boat or other veh icle or major parts thereof. AA. The keeping or maintenance in any area on private property which is clearly visible from a public street, sidewalk, park or other public area any accumulation, collection or untidy storage of any of the following: old appliances or parts thereof; old iron, steel, aluminum or other metal; inoperable vehicles, vehicle parts, machinery or equipment; mattresses, bedding, clothing, rags or cloth; straw, packing materials, cardboard or paper, tin cans, wire, bottles, glass, cans, barrels, bins, boxes, containers, ashes, plaster or cement; or wood. This determination shall not apply to conditions completely enclosed within a building or fencing so as not to be visible from public property. BB. The keeping, permitting or harboring of any fowl, pigeons, rabbits, hoofed or cloven footed animals, except for caged birds kept within a residence or business. Exhibit 1 Page 3 of 4 CC. The depositing of any debris, vegetation, lawn clippings, lumber piles, wood piles, auto parts or bodies, garbage and the like, or storing of any material of any kind, provided that in residential zones that shall include garbage cans or refuse containers in the alleys of the city, except on garbage pickup day. DD. The existence of graffiti, which is defined as a defacing, damaging, or destructive inscription, figure or design painted, drawn or the like, on the exterior of any building, fence, gate, or other structures or on rocks, bridges, trees, or other real or personal property. EE. The locating of automobiles, trucks, recreational vehicles, trailers, boats, or any other vehicles, vessels, or the like for the purpose of advertising its sale on property located in any commercial or industrial zone not owned by the seller. FF. The permitting of any condition or situation where the soil has been disrupted, disturbed, or destablized so as to allow blowing dust to exist. GG. The existence on any premise any unsecured, unused, or abandoned building or structures. H H. For any building the existence of any broken glass in windows or doors for more than thirty (30) days. II. Buildings or portions thereof that have faulty weather protection, such as openings in walls and roofs. Faulty weather protection shall include temporary weather barriers, such as tarps, plastic or similar material, left in place for more than thirty (30) days. JJ. Any building which has a window, door, or other exterior opening closed by extrinsic devices or some other manner, with material that has not been painted to match or compliment the buildings exterior or remains boarded up for more than sixty (60) days. KK. Any boarded up building that remains boarded up for more than ninety (90) days. LL Permitting any violation of RCW 59.18.510 in any rental dwelling unit. MM. Criminal street gangs and any pattern of criminal street gang activity are each declared to be a public nuisance in violation of this chapter and other applicable code provisions, including but not limited to the Uniform Code for the Abatement of Dangerous Buildings and State Housing Code, subject to abatement through all available means. In addition thereto and without limitation, any pattern of criminal street gang activity upon, and the presence and use of property by, a criminal street gang, with the owner's knowledge or consent, constitutes a public nuisance and grounds for revocation of any permit or license regulating or authorizing the use of such property. Exh ibit 1 Page 4 of 4 CITY Of MOSES LAKE NOTICE TO CORRECT UNSAFE OR UNLAWFUL CONDITION DATED: ISSUED TO: 5/6/2014 Pedro Sanchez 812 S 4th Ave Pasco, Wa. 99301-5708 LOCATION OF UNLAWFUL CONDITION: 1170 S Grand dr, Moses Lake, WA 98837 DESCRIPTION: Weeds and grasses in excess of 12" in height are present in the front yard and along the driveway of this home. Moses Lake Municipal Code Section No.: 8.14.030U Maintenance of grasses, weeds, etc As owner,agent,lessee, other person occupying or having charge or control of the building, lot or premises at 1170 S Grand dr, you are hereby notified that the undersigned, pursuant to Chapter 8.14.0300 of the Moses Lake Municipal Code, has determined that there exists upon or adjoining said premises the following conditions: Weeds and grasses in excess of 12" in height are present in the front yard and along the driveway of this home. This is contrary to the provisions of the Moses Lake Municipal Code Section number 8.14.030U 8.14.030U Except for any designated public park land, natural area, or environmentally sensitive area, or any undeveloped parcels of land not adjacent to developed areas or which are used for agricultural purposes, all grasses, weeds, or other vegetation growing or which has grown and died, which is determined to be a fire or safety hazard or a nuisance to persons, shall not exceed twelve inches (12") in height measured above the ground. 1. The above exception may be waived and additional maintenance required by the Code Enforcement Officer if he determines such action is necessary to protect the safety of persons or adjoining property. 2. All maintenance shall be done in a manner so that soil stability will not be disrupted or disturbed. Grass, weed, or vegetation control shall not include plowing, discing, or scraping the soil to eliminate the grasses, weeds, or other vegetation unless a soil stabilization plan, which will minimize blowing dust and maintain soil stability and which shall be approved by the city prior to any plowing, discing, or scraping, is implemented immediately. Exhibit 2 Page 1of2 City Manager 764-3701 ·City Attorney 764-3703 ·Community Development 764-3750 ·Finance 764-3717 ·Fire 765-2204 Municipal Services 764-3 783 ·Municipal Court 764-3701 ·Parks & Recreation 764-3805 ·Police 764-3887 ·Fax 764-3739 401 S Balsam St.· P.O. Drawer 1579 ·Moses Lake, WA 98837-0244 · www.cityofml.com You are notified to correct said condition to the satisfaction of the undersigned within 10 days of the date of this notice. If you do not correct the condition within the specified time period, a notice and order to correct the condition will be issued to you, which can result in a penalty being imposed. CORRECTION REQUIRED: Weeds and grasses must be cut down and or removed from these areas. I would like to thank you in advance for your cooperating efforts. If you have questions or need clarification on any of the above-mentioned items, please give me a call at 509-764-3748 or come see me at City Hall. Sincerely, . _ / /,/. ~~ Brett Hollen Code Enforcement bhollen@cityofinl.com Exhibit 2 Page 2 of 2 CITY OF MOSES LAKE CITY OF MOSES LAKE NOTICE OF VIOLATION AND ORDER TO CORRECT OR CEASE ACTIVITY TO: Pedro Sanchez 812 S 4th Ave Pasco, Wa. 99301-5708 NOTICE OF VIOLATION Provisions of the City of Moses Lake Code Violated: Moses Lake Municipal Code 8.14.030U Street Address of Violation: 1170 S Grand dr, Moses Lake, WA 98837 Brief Legal Description of Property Where Violation Exists: Lot 9 Block Hayden Estates Second Add 111956000 YOU ARE HEREBY ORDERED TO CORRECT OR CEASE THE ACTIVITY AS FOLLOWS: Action Necessary to Correct Violation: Weeds and grasses must be cut down and or removed from these areas. Time by Which Violation is to be Corrected or Activty Ceased The City is requiring these corrections listed on this Notice and Order be accomplished by Sunday,June,01,2014 YOU ARE FURTHER NOTIFIED THAT THE MOSES LAKE CITY CODE PROVIDES FOR THE FOLLOWING PENAL TIES: Exhibit 3 Page 1 of 2 City Manager 764-3701 ·City Attorney 764-3703 ·Community Development 764-3750 ·Finance 764-3717 ·Fire 765-2204 Municipal Services 764-3783 ·Municipal Court 764-3701 ·Parks & Recreation 764-3805 ·Police 764-3887 ·Fax 764-3739 401 S Balsam St .. P.O. Drawer 1579 ·Moses Lake, WA 98837-0244 · www.cityofml.com I. Any violation for which a Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity has been issued but which has not been corrected within the the time specified shall incur a civil penalty of two hundred fifty dollars ($250) per day up to a sum of five thousand dollars ($5000), beginning on the day the correction was to be completed. The cumulative penalty provided for in this paragraph shall not accrue while an appeal is pending, nor shall the penalty preclude the initiation of appropriate legal action to correct the violation. [l.20.0SO(E)(l)]. 2. If a penalty has been assessed pursuantto l.20.050(E)(l ), a Court shall assess that penalty and any additional penalty the Court considers appropriate plus court costs and attorney's fees. YOU MAY APPEAL IBIS NOTICE AND ORDER TO THE HEARING EXAMINER WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS, PURSUANT TO SECTION 20.03 .050 OF THE MOSES LAKE CITY CODE AND BY PAYMENT OF AN $800 FEE. YOU ARE FURTHER NOTIFIED THAT IF THE AFOREMENTIONED VIOLATION IS NOT CORRECTED AS SPECIFIED HERIN THIS MA TIER WILL BE REFERRED TO THE CITY ATTORNEY FOR CIVIL ENFORCEMENT BY INJUNCTION OR OTHER APROPRIATE ACTION. Dated this Thursday, May 22, 2014 Brett Hollen Code Enforcement City of Moses Lake 509-764-3748 Exhibit 3 Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 4 Page 2 of 3 /. June, 24, 2014 Pedro Sanchez 812 S 4th Ave Pasco, Wa. 99301-5708 CITY OF MOSES LAKE Re: Hearing to Permit City Abatement of Nuisance Property located at: 1170 S Grand dr, Parcel 111956000, Moses Lake, WA 98837 Via Regular Mail and Return Receipt Mail Pedro Sanchez You are identified in the records of the Grant County Assessor as the record owner of real property located within the City of Moses Lake described as: Lot 9 Block Hayden Estates Second Add. This property is located at: 1170 S Grand dr, Parcel 111956000, Moses Lake, WA 98837 On Thursday, May 22, 2014 the City of Moses Lake mailed to you by regular mail and return receipt mail a Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity within the time allowed by the City Code. The time specified in that Notice of Violation and Order to Correct or Cease Activity has expired without compliance. As of June 24, 2014, the nuisance located on the subject property has not been corrected or removed. Pursuant to Moses Lake Municipal Code (MLMC) 8.14.070 the City of Moses Lake is giving you notice that it will conduct a hearing before the Moses Lake City Council at the Council's regular meeting on Tuesday, July 08, 2014 which is more than ten days from the date of this letter. That meeting will begin at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers in the Moses Lake Civic Center. The purpose of this hearing is for the City Council to determine if a nuisance exists on your property and if a nuisance is found to exist to direct the abatement of that nuisance by use of City contracted forces. The cost of that abatement will be assessed against you as the owner of the subject property. At that hearing all persons interested in the abatement of the nuisance existing on the subject property will have the opportunity to be heard under oath. At that time, you may present all relevant evidence you wish for the City Council to consider, whether that be documents, photos, or live testimony from yourself or others. At the conclusion of that hearing, it is expected the City Council will determine if an abatement of a nuisance located on the subject property should take place and when. TIDS HEARING IS IMPORTANT. YOUR FAILURE TO PARTICIPATE MAY IMPACT IMPORTANT RIGHTS IN YOUR PROPERTY. If you have any questions, you may contact the City Manager's Office at the Moses Lake Civic Center, 401 S. Balsam, Moses Lake, WA, phone 509-764-3701. Sincerely, ~ Ric~guez • · Code Enforcement Officer cc: City Manager City Attorney Community Development Director Exhibit 5 City Manager 764-3701 ·City Attorney 764-3703 ·Community Development 764-3750 ·Finance 764-3717 ·Fire 765-2204 Municipal Services 764-3 783 ·Municipal Court 764-3 701 ·Parks & Recreation 764-3805 ·Police 764-3887 ·Fax 764-3739 401 S Balsam St.· P.O. Drawer 1579 ·Moses Lake, WA 98837-0244 · www.cityofml.com July 1, 2014 TO: City Manager For City Council Consideration FROM: Municipal Services Director SUBJECT: Request to Call for Bids Clover Lift Station Project-2014 Staff is nearing completion of the plans and specifications for the Clover Lift Station Project- 2014. The project includes complete reconstruction of the existing lift station including new pumps and electrical, site grading, and site improvements. The estimated construction cost for the project is $330,000. Preliminary plans and specifications will be available at the engineering office for review. Staff is requesting to advertise this contract for bids. Respectfully Submitted\\ o::::J~~-~ Municipal Services Director July 2, 2014 TO: City Manager for Council Consideration FROM: Community Development Director SUBJECT: Draft Shoreline Master Program -Recommendation to Department of Ecology The City Council at their regular scheduled meeting on June 241h considered the final Draft Shoreline Master Program (SMP) and closed the public hearing on the Draft plan. Staff mentioned to the Council that the comment period would remain open until June 30th in order to comply with the 60- daynotice ofintentto adopt requirements (RCW36.70A.106/W AC 173-26-100(5)). Comments were received after the June 24th City Council meeting and within the June 30th comment period deadline. The only comments received after the June 24th meeting were from the Washington State Department of Ecology (DOE). Attached are the DOE comments. Procedurally, the City Council has conducted a public hearing and comments were received. Prior to approval of the Draft SMP, the City Council must prepare a responsive summary within the 60- day notice period and prior to SMP approval. Given the DOE comments received, the Council is not in a position to make a recommendation on the Draft SMP until after a responsive summary is prepared. The City Council should consider the comments received on the Draft SMP and direct staff on how to proceed. The Council should keep in mind the local approval process and consider preparing a responsive summary. Respectfully submitted Gilbert~ Community Development Director June 27, 2014 TO: City Manager for Council Consideration FROM: Community Development Director SUBJECT: Platting Deemed Insufficient -1102 Terrace Dale and Debra Hellewell submitted a building permit application forthe W 51' of Lot 4 and the E 32' of Lot 5, Block 4, North Terrace Addition, located at 1102 Terrace Avenue, which are legally platted parcels. At the time the property was platted, the development did not require municipal improvements that are now required with current plats. Municipal improvements could include the extension or provision of City water, sewer, storm sewer, curb, sidewalks, street or other provisions. Since the legally platted parcel does not meet our current municipal improvements standards, it falls under the provisions of MLMC 16. 02 .110, Platting Deemed Insufficient. A building permit cannot be issued for this property unless the property is brought into conformance with the standards of our current plat improvements or the City Council grants a waiver, deferral, or deviation from the requirements to install the deficient plat improvements. The applicant has chosen to request a deferral from the requirement to install improvements pursuant to MLMC 16.02.110 B. The City Council has considered requests in the past for building permits for parcels that fall under the provisions of MLMC 16.02.110. The provisions of MLMC 16.02 .11 O(B) were considered in the granting of such requests. If the Council is inclined to grant the request, staff would recommend that a covenant securing future municipal improvements be required. Respectfully submitted (;fv Gilbert Alvarado Community Development Director GA:jt CITY OF MOSES LAKE MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 16.02 -BUILDING PERMITS 16.02.100 Revocation of Business License: Failure or refusal to comply with any provision of this Chapter or an order or directive of the Building Official issued pursuant hereto shall constitute grounds for revocation of the violators city business license following a hearing as provided in th is Code. (Ord. 2330, 6/12/07; Ord. 2172, 7127104; Ord. 2073, 7/23/02) 16.02.110 Platting Deemed Insufficient-When: A. Property located within the city which is presently platted and which property was platted without the extension or provision of city water, city sewer, storm sewer, curb, sidewalk, streets or other improvements through some or all of the lots of the plat shall be deemed to be unplatted for purposes of the issuance of any development permit or building permit. Any lot so affected shall be permitted to develop and a building permit will be issued upon the installation of city water, city sewer, storm drains, curbs, sidewalks, streets, and other improvements to community standards, including fire protection devices, or upon the posting of security in an amount approved by the city, which is equal to the estimated cost of the extensions and/or improvements remaining to be installed through the lot, in a form acceptable to the City Attorney to insure the construction of the required improvements and extensions at the same time as construction of the building for which the building permit was issued or at the time of the improvement of the affected lot. B. Any property owner can make application to the City Council for a waiver, deferral, or deviation from or of the requirement to install improvements. A waiver, deferral, or deviation from or of the requirement to install improvements shall not be granted unless the City Council finds that because of the nature of the property, its topography, the conditions or nature of the adjoining areas or the existence of unusual physical conditions, the requirement to install improvements would cause an unusual and unnecessary hardship on the property owner. In granting a waiver, deferral or deviation from or of the requirements to install improvements, the City Council may require such conditions as will secure the objectives of the requirement waived, deferred, or deviated from or of. Any waiver, deferral, or deviation authorized shall be entered in the minutes of the Moses Lake City Council together with the circumstances that justify the waiver, deferral, or deviation granted. (Ord. 2564, 6/22/10; Ord. 2391, 5/13/08) 9 -11 (6/10) -' -•' .. . . . ~ > '.• .. CITY ~OF MOSES LAKE Community Development JUN t:\2iaMBalsam St Moses Lake, WA 98837 c"'" cc:;~:·_·;: -: (509)7-6'4":]755 Application Date :_--'(f'-'/;~1,_./J"--=lf----='-- '/( v.J Moses LAKE PJ '· ,,.,_ cso9) 764(87s8 Fax CG~ ur . .'. -:.:: .. L,~u:: Assessor's Tax Parcel Numbers(s): Legal Description/Subdivision Name: Building Permit Change in Use Grading Manufactured Home Permit Relocation Sign Tenant(New/Change) Other Lot Area: Zoning: R~ Corner Lot?: Front: Rear: Left: Right: Exterior Side: Setbacks 33~2 ~0~2-f 6 I 15 1 (Corner Lots) OWNER/ APPLICANT INFORMATION Indicate who sho.,ld be contacted regarding this project ' Owner: Phone: 509 '-f3! O?r/0 ~pplicant: Phone: 5 0 q 1 ~I C~'lO ~ DQl~ t-le.tL6J e\\ 1-t. Dctf e. J-/ e_({ e,u) e.. '-l Fax: Fax: Mailing Address: svJ Mailing Address: CfZ,~o I~ oo.d ff g390 'Ro<id ~ 91 City, State, Zip City, State, Zip nth.ell o L.f/ A q Cf?A-L/-' Ot~e..U o iJA t]9?A'f :ontractor: Phone:5 0 q '1g.-, 1-/-<+q t..f Architect/Engineer: Phone: ~~DY ~P--6'.S Fax:.)oq1'ii! 4t\~4-Fax: Mailing Address: Mailing Address: p e ~'1--l 00\ ~ity, State, Zip City, State, Zip Pp*~IA Lt{A C\~3'L3 WA State Contractor License# City Business License # :ontact Name: r.<-o~~kE:..ooo QJ Expiration a e: z-? a_; c;.. PROJECT INFORMATION I Cost of Project: Building Information ccupancy Grou Dimensions 21&.',...g )(, s #of stories 2nd floor sq ft nfinished basement sq ft Wo\JE #J'E Garage sq ft >JoJS Deck sq ft overed Porch sq ft Building Permit Application.pub 2010 0 1----t---; I ~--+--i l I _ J _ - ---HAWTHq·RNE:l5R---j ~-+--i I I 625F e1 -COUNCIL AGENDA SITE 1-----._ ___ J CITY LIMITS --·-·--·-·-·.J UGA BOUNDARY CENTERLINE MOSES LAKE PLATTING DEEMED INSUFFICIENT HOSES L.AKE CITY OF MOSES LAKE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DIVISION Date: 613012014 CMS June 27, 2014 TO: City Manager for Council Consideration FROM: Community Development Director SUBJECT: Platting Deemed Insufficient -1140 Pioneer Way Bud Clary Ford submitted a building permit application for Lot 3 less Tax #14395, Swanson Addition Amendment, located at 1140 S. Pioneer Way, which is a legally platted parcel. At thetime the property was platted, the development did not require municipal improvements that are now required with current plats. Municipal improvements could include the extension or provision of City water, sewer, storm sewer, curb, sidewalks, street or other provisions. Since the legally platted parcel does not meet our current municipal improvements standards, it falls under the provisions of MLMC 16.02.110, Platting Deemed Insufficient. A building permit cannot be issued for this property unless the property is brought into conformance with the standards of our current plat improvements or the City Council grants a waiver, deferral, or deviation from the requirements to install the deficient plat improvements. The applicant has chosen to request a deferral from the requirement to install improvements pursuant to MLMC 16.02 .110 B. The City Council has considered requests in the past for building permits for parcels that fall under the provisions of MLMC 16.02.110. The provisions of MLMC 16.02.11 O(B) were considered in the granting of such requests. If the Council is inclined to grant the request, staff would recommend that a covenant securing future municipal improvements be required. Respe~mitted Gilbert Alvarado Community Development Director GA:jt CITY OF MOSES LAKE MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 16.02 • BUILDING PERMITS 16.02.100 Revocation of Business License: Failure or refusal to comply with any provision of this Chapter or an order or directive of the Building Official issued pursuant hereto shall constitute grounds for revocation of the violators city business license following a hearing as provided in this Code. (Ord. 2330, 6/12/07; Ord. 2172, 7/27/04; Ord. 2073, 7/23/02) 16.02.110 Platting Deemed Insufficient -When: A. Property located within the city which is presently platted and which property was platted without the extension or provision of city water, city sewer, storm sewer, curb, sidewalk, streets or other improvements through some or all of the lots of the plat shall be deemed to be unplatted for purposes of the issuance of any development permit or building permit. Any lot so affected shall be permitted to develop and a building permit will be issued upon the installation of city water, city sewer, storm drains, curbs, sidewalks, streets, and other improvements to community standards, including fire protection devices, or upon the posting of security in an amount approved by the city, which is equal to the estimated cost of the extensions and/or improvements remaining to be installed through the lot, in a form acceptable to the City Attorney to insure the construction of the required improvements and extensions at the same time as construction of the building for which the building permit was issued or at the time of the improvement of the affected lot. 8. Any property owner can make application to the City Council for a waiver, deferral, or deviation from or of the requirement to install improvements. A waiver, deferral, or deviation from or of the requirement to install improvements shall not be granted unless the City Council finds that because of the nature of the property, its topography, the conditions or nature of the adjoining areas or the existence of unusual physical conditions, the requirement to install improvements would cause an unusual and unnecessary hardship on the property owner. In granting a waiver, deferral or deviation from or of the requirements to install improvements, the City Council may require such conditions as will secure the objectives of the requirement waived, deferred, or deviated from or of. Any waiver, deferral, or deviation authorized shall be entered in the minutes of the Moses Lake City Council together with the circumstances that justify the waiver, deferral, or deviation granted. (Ord. 2564, 6/22/10; Ord. 2391, 5/13/08) 9 -11 (6/10) _ .1evrolet ·Chrysler· Doo~) ·Ford· Honda Jeep · Ram · Scion · Subaru · Toyota Longview • Moses Lake • Yakima June 04, 2014 City Council City of Moses Lake 40 I S Balsam Moses Lake WA 98837 JUN 1 7 2014 RE: COMMll•\iTV n~:VEi.OP\P'NT Ford of Moses Lake Expansion and Renovation PL~~~l.';G ,I\: !H.iILHJNu" Request for waiver/deferral of Street improvements CJ 1 ~ Uf· !HOSES LAKE East State Street Council; Under Section 16.02.110.A of the Moses Lake Municipal code our expansion and renovation project for Ford of Moses Lake is required to install sidewalks, street and curb to the centerline of an undeveloped street. The current unimproved East State Street is a dead end cul-de-sac with developed multiple family housing to the west of our project site. The property to the south is currently undeveloped. Construction of partial street improvements to East State street south will result in a partial street improvement without connection to improved Balsam Street west of the project. Based on the nature of existing undeveloped street improvements on East State Street, west of the project we request a waiver/deferral to Section 16.02.110.A as allowed in Section 16.02.11 O.B until such time as East State Street is developed to Balsam Street and the property on the south side of East State Street is developed. Should you have any additional questions or require additional information to make your detem1ination please contact Strotkamp Architects, David Estes, at 425-316-8979 or 206-979- 8320. Thanks you for your consideration on this issue r ent Clary Moses Lake Properties LLC CC; David Estes, Strotkamp Architects Tom Strotkamp, Strotkamp Architects Kelly Vernon, JHKelly Contractors Bud Clary Auto Group, P.O. Box 127, Longview, WA 98632, Phone -360.423.1700, Fax 360.636.5065 WVl/W. budclary.com ?t~~J ~ E. D ~~; a~:_ CITY OF MOSES LAKE ~~ J~hili)Qhlity Development '.AV": 321 S Balsam St t:>?~~~~~~.~ .. ~ COMMUNITY ~l.m't{~~WA 98837 c IH ., PLANNING & Bl(~~9'64-3756 MOSES LA fC.6 CITY OF MO~~"f-~~4-3758 Fax FOR STAFF USE Per;mlt Numper: JJ.@) If& /fl Cfi · Appll€atlon . Date: V:!_/J7:(/Jf r1 Staff Representative·~~ti.-....W........,. __ ___.._, BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION 1 Street Address: \ l 'TO Bulldlng Permit Change In Use Grading )( Manufactured Home Permit Relocation Sign Tenant(New/Change) Other Lot Area: t ~~. l \'L~ zoning a Corner Lot?: f'i 0 Front: Left: Right: Exterior Side: Set backs l'5' <:jJ ontact Name. C~J\O '@'} 1 Cb "'-1'¥\o#f;?&o Building Information uildlng height to peak '2-'tl ... {)l' nfinished basement sq ft t,. ~. eek sq ft N~ Bulldlng Permit Application.pub 2010 P"th: \\GiNt>no~r\gislMastuY\COUNC/l MA.PS.mxd I -------1'-----H/.L:a:-AVE : 'a: Q 'Q' ·~ -~ :~ ' r ---1 BALL-C I -COUNCIL AGENDA SITE ·----.. ._ ___ J CITY LIMITS UGA BOUNDARY CENTERLINE MOSES LAKE PLATTING DEEMED INSUFFICIENT HOSES LAKE CITY OF MOSES LAKE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PLANNING DIVISION Date: 613012014 CMS July 1, 2014 TO: City Manager For City Council Consideration FROM: Municipal Services Director SUBJECT: Request for Group B Water System Bob Hammon -Lot 6, less Kopps Golden Acres Bob Hammon requests approval to allow a Group B water system to serve Lot 6, less Kopps Golden Acres. Bob is planning on subdividing this parcel. This property is within the City's unincorporated UGA, which is the City's water service area. The Grant County Coordinated Water System Plan requires approval from the City before creating new Group A and Group B water systems within its service area. It must be shown that it is unreasonable to connect to the City's water system. The City's water main would need to be extended approximately 4,000 feet to serve this property. This request is presented for Council consideration. R;t:;br,~~ Gary Harer, PE/PLS Municipal Services Director Request for city water and sewer June 24 2014 Property is located on the West side of the lake at the South end of Kopps Lane just past Moses Pointe Golf Course. Tax# 121656000 Kopps Golden Acres Lot #6 Moses Lake City Counsil: I am contacting you about the possibility of connecting my property to the city water supply. I made a proposal to Grant County to long plat my 10 acres into eight home lots with a class B water system for potable water and using irrigation water from Moses Lake for landscape watering. The county is very supportive of my plan. It was during this process, that I discovered my property is in the Moses Lake UGA. When I approached the city planning dept to ask if I would be able to put a class B well in, my request was denied. I was told my next action would be to contact the city council as I am doing now. The Moses Lake City water main which runs along Westside Drive ends one mile from my property. feel the main reason the city did not extend the main past the entrance to the Moses Pointe Golf Course, is the 4000 feet after the end of the main is golf course property. Beyond the golf course property is a dead end road with approximately 12 existing homes currently on wells. It is my understanding that the city has no future plans to extend the water main from where it currently ends. Can you verify this or provide me with any plans the city might have to provide water to the remaining UGA property in my area. For me to extend the water line myself is more than the value of my property. I am not sure how, why or when my parcel was declared part of the UGA but the property just west of me was not? Looking at the City of Moses Lake UGA map it just doesn't make too much sense. The city made a decision to make my property a part of the UGA, now my greatest fear is the city has no plans to ever extend services to my property, won't allow me to have a well and causes my land to have almost a zero value. I don't think by any stretch of the imagination that this is a fare thing to do to anyone. If the city and city council are unwilling to allow me a class B well or connect me to the water main, I would like to know what it would take to remove my property from the UGA. Thank you very much for any help you can give us. Bob and Jan Hammon 1030 Saint Andrews Dr Cle Elum, WA 98922 Home 509-674-5525 Cell 206-940-4286 ~' ' .... ....... I-< Q Moses Pointe ----...... ,Golf Course City Water Main June 2014 Billie Munoz City of Moses Lake PO Box 1579 Moses Lake, WA 98837 Dear Billie, Congratulations on earning the 2014 AWC Employee Benefit Trust WellCity Award! City of Moses Lake is one of 96 cities and quasi-municipal entities that have earned the Trust's WellCity Award. You'll also receive a 2% premium discount on your medical premiums in 2015. Award materials Your WellCity Award road sign, 2014 year plate, window clings and wellness committee certificates are attached. Remember to affix your 2014 plate to your WellCity Award plaque, showing your continuing health promotion efforts. Remember to reapply each year to maintain your WellCity status and 2% discount. WellCity recognition Be sure to read the May/June issue of Cityvision magazine and look for the ad celebrating WellCities -it's right on the back cover. A banner showcasing WellCities was displayed at the AWC Annual Conference, and will be displayed at Member Programs Expo and Healthy Worksite Summit. The Annual Conference Awards Breakfast featured a WellCity video and slideshow. The enclosed WellCity brochures feature those that earned the Award. We've included some extras for you to share with your council and wellness committee, or to display in your lobby. You can access the WellCity press release template on our website in the Trust's members only Wellness/WellCity Awards section. It takes commitment Employers play a vital role in building a workplace that supports healthy behaviors. Earning the WellCity Award takes a commitment by your elected officials, management and staff. The comprehensive requirements reflect a broad-based strategy supporting employee health and productivity resulting in reduced health care costs. Thank you for your commitment to employee health and the leadership you have shown among Washington cities and towns and across the nation. Your wellness program is a model for others to emulate. If you need additional certificates, window clings or brochures, contact Laura Langston at laural@awcnet.org. ely, Mike McCa y Chief Executive Officer cc: Dick Deane, Mayor Joseph Gavinski, City Manager July 1, 2014 TO: FROM: SUBJECT: Please find the attached Ambulance Cash Report for the month ending June 30, 2014. Cc: Fire Chief AMBULANCE CASH OPERATION JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUNE Y-T-D REVENUE Collected on ALS/BLS/mileage $ 82,370.41 96,096.47 95,030.05 108,506.26 144,605.52 134,974.69 $ 661,583.40 Utility charge 81,391.66 69,169.30 74,526.54 75,807.51 77,187.52 72,774.19 450,856.72 State grant -Stay at work 1,649.81 1,649.81 State grant -EMS 1,473.00 1,473.00 Reimbursement from police 44.86 44.86 Reimbursement from fire 11,048.76 7,240.96 7,467.88 10,668.25 8,332.50 6,672.81 51,431.16 misc 278.00 278.00 closure of debt service total cash received from operations $ 174,810.83 172,506.73 178,674.28 196,733.02 230,170.40 214,421.69 $ 1,167,316.95 EXPENDITURE labor $ 154,481.74 93,661.02 103,067.11 104,461.15 103,173.15 106,885.86 $ 665,730.03 benfits 45,583.23 39,660.90 40,762.36 40,471.12 40,567.91 39,745.06 246,790.58 supplies 3,270.14 5,425.04 4,989.53 6,072.06 5,259.76 4,448.58 29,465.11 services/repairs 22,146.74 24,390.21 25,706.71 29,551.96 25,510.32 30,744.24 158,050.18 transfers 33,850.00 33,855.00 33,855.00 33,855.00 33,855.00 33,855.00 203,125.00 capital purchases interest - -1,014.95 1,014.95 total expenditures $ 259,331.85 196,992.17 208,380.71 215,426.24 208,366.14 215,678.74 $ 1,043,340.68 Net income (loss) before G.F. contribution (84,521.02) (24,485.44) (29,706.43) (18,693.22) 21,804.26 (1,257.05) (136,858.90) contribution from general fund 22,980.00 22,982.00 22,982.00 22,982.00 22,982.00 22,982.00 137,890.00 net income (loss) $ (61,541.02) (1,503.44) (6,724.43) 4,288.78 44,786.26 21,724.95 $ 1,031.10 Cash position Sterling 195,958.44 179,802.59 174,148.89 140,405.08 148,482.10 180,172.41 US Bank 84,168.87 98,793.75 97,657.02 111,298.15 146,522.98 105,210.29 280,127.31 278,596.34 271,805.91 251,703.23 295,005.08 285,382.70 change in total cash from previous month (62,425.99) (1,530.97) (6,790.43) (20,102.68} 43,301.85 (9,622.38) SAAS 222 221 257 237 262 billed 193 203 233 214 July 2, 2014 TO: City Manager for Council Consideration FROM: Finance Director SUBJECT: Council Financial Report The Council Financial Report for the period ended June 30, 2014 has been posted, for the Council and public review, on the City's website. June 20, 2014 TO: City Manager FROM: Utility Account Technician ~ SUBJECT: Investment Report Attached is the Investment Report for the month of May, 2014. cc: Finance Director Investment Report MAY 2014 Investment Investment Amount Interest Purchase Maturity Interest With Type Rate Date Date Earned Investments Outstanding Total Outstanding: $0.00 Investment Maturities Grant County Invest Pool Invest Acct 10,078,872.68 1.65 05/01/2014 05/31/2014 14,797.78 Wa. State Invest Pool Invest Acct 5,049,411.25 0.92 05/01/2014 05/31/2014 399.03 Total Maturities: 15, 128,283.93 Investment Purchases Grant County Invest Pool Invest Acct 11 ,093,670.46 Wa. State Invest Pool Invest Acct 6, 126,272.89 Total Purchases: 17,219,943.35 Investment Totals Beginning Balance * 15,128,283.93 Total Maturities 15,128,283.93 Total Purchases 17,219,943.35 Endinq Balance* 17,219,943.35 I Month Iv Interest Earned 15, 196.81 * Beginning Balance =Total Outstanding +Total Maturities *Ending Balance= Beginning Balance -Total Maturities +Total Purchases July 1, 2014 Honorable Mayor and Moses Lake City Council Dear Council Members CI T Y OF MOSES LAKE Attached is sales tax information for April 2014 sales which the City received on June 30, 2014. This report indicates the City received $475,371.67. The $475 ,371.67 in receipts for June, compares with June 2013 receipts of $437,909.92 . For the year, the 2014 receipts are approximately 9% higher than the 2013 receipts for the same period. Also provided is the transient rental income report for income the City received on June 30, 2014. This report indicates June 30 , 2014 income (for Ap ril sales) of $41 ,151.98 . This compares with $38,830.04 for the same period in 2013. For the year, transient rental income receipts are approximately 4% higher than the 2013 receipts for the same period . Respectfully submitted Joseph K. Gavinski City Manager JKG:sg City Manager 764-3701 •City Attorney 764-3703 •Community Development 764-3750 •Finance 764-3717 •Fire 765-2204. Municipal Services 764-3783 •Municipal Court 764-3701 •Parks & Recreation 764-3805 •Police 764-3887 •Fax 764-3739 401 S Balsam St.• P.O. Box 1579 •Moses Lake, WA 98837-0224 • www.cityofml.com Sales Tax Receipts -Monthly Month Sales YTD Received Period 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Change Jan Nov 373,688.80 367,830.83 403,504.15 401,499.05 430, 110.34 7% Feb Dec 560,731 .77 488,453.72 459,218.16 491 ,341.62 537,941 .54 8% Mar Jan 276,352.86 324,247.20 331,644.01 373,707.66 443,309.81 11% Apr Feb 330,932.86 368,305.65 350,818.56 364,137.97 402,265.84 11% May Mar 402,951 .97 456,738.86 405,657.25 475,345.89 476,064.44 9% June Apr 384,565.04 439,396.45 399,414.06 437,909.92 475,371.67 9% July May 380,216.47 431 ,750.56 419,629.64 478,822.77 Aug June 456,372.87 453,961 .67 432,420.11 460,309.61 Sept July 407,935.17 411,796.14 407,813.31 457,908.37 Oct Aug 390,800.44 446,905.90 455,185.85 511 ,513.84 Nov Sept 438,011 .36 411 ,689.43 422,198.39 465,603.85 Dec Oct 394, 167.42 406,648.97 424, 167.87 441 ,278.01 Totals 4 796,727.03 5,007 725.38 4,911 671 .36 5 359 378.56 2 765 063.64 TRANSIENT RENTAL INCOME -MONTHLY TOTAL RECEIVED MONTH SALES YTD RECEIVED PERIOD 2011 2012 2013 2014 Change JAN NOV 39,728.66 25,073.90 37,239.62 33,221.58 -11 % FEB DEC 25, 155.98 26,277.18 19,145.26 28,737.22 10% MAR JAN 30,274.86 28,091 .94 32,692.16 26,058.10 -1% APRIL FEB 35,015.70 22,286.68 22,967.86 31,468.50 7% MAY MAR 31 ,217.30 25,787.06 36,755.64 34,621.22 4% JUNE APRIL 43, 150.52 35,334.86 38,830.04 41 ,151 .98 4% JULY MAY 65,576.42 45,674.12 64,910.04 AUGUST JUNE 57,975.95 55,497.56 49, 135.32 SEPT JULY 55,399.42 53,987.68 62,363.32 OCT AUGUST 62,457.58 57,117.62 68,846.76 NOV SEPT 48,256.58 46,866.78 57,668.74 DEC OCT 37,670.80 34,675.70 41,957.82 TOTALS 531 879.77 456 671.08 532 512.58 195 258.60